HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - To heck with KE formulas and theories
View Single Post
Old 04-22-2005 | 03:13 PM
  #211  
Straightarrow
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,413
Likes: 0
From:
Default RE: To heck with KE formulas and theories

KE is by definition the distance an arrow can push with a given amount of force. Momentum is by definition the time an arrow can push with a given amount of force. If you can find me an engineer who says that Ke is not a good indicator of penetration potential I will show you an engineer who flunked his mechanics course!
If that is the definition of KE when applied to archery, the formula does not take into account what happens when friction increases dramatically when an arrows path is diverted in the body of an animal - and it always is, at least a little. I'm not an engineer, but I do not believe that KE is a good indicator of pentration potential of broadhead tipped arrow passing through an animal's body. Plain and simple, it's dead last on my list of concerns. However momentum is not dead last. It's a step ahead of KE. The reason is simple. I know that with no more effort on the shot, I can decrease the likelihood of deflection by simply increasing momentum in the easiest manner - using a heavier arrow. Since momentum is increased at a greater rate, it has to have more importance than a factor that is increased by a lesser rate. If it wasn't true, then it wouldn't matter if I just increased KE by drawing more poundage. However, it does matter. Increasing arrow weight has a more significant influence on momentum with no more effort.
Straightarrow is offline  
Reply