121553

Question is not clear. You mean eating or hunting?

Taste ****** Whitetail
Hunting antlers ** Mule deer
Prefer hunting*** Either/or
Last year I got a 4x4 white tail and this year I got a 3x3 mulie, within a 1/4 mile of each other. The mule deer has a stronger taste (not bad or gamey) just stronger. The white tails that I have gotten in this same area, eating the same thing as the mule deer taste much better.
If you want antlers than go for mulies. Bobby

JD IN ALBERTA

I love 'em both...each is difficult and unique in it's own wat that makes me love hunting either species! JDinAB

jepcho

I'd definately say the whitetail!!

messenger516

whitetails by all means!

JerseyJim

I've never hunted mule so I have to go with whitetail!

jones123

[/quote]

If you want antlers than go for mulies. Bobby
[/quote]

I have wondered about that. I agree here in Montana, it seems like mulies definitely have the antler edge. But based only on photos and tv, seems like a whitetail from east of here that is considered "decent" would have as big of a rack than a western muley that scores "decent".

plainsman

Muley by far

skeeter 7MM

I like them both, each bring their own challenges and rewards. If made to choose I prefer hunting whitetails. Taste no contest Whitetail gets the nod.

treehunter

we don't have mule deer here. I wouldn't mind traveling and trying my hand at it. I do really like hunting whitetails though.