RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

Question is not clear. You mean eating or hunting?

Taste ****** Whitetail
Hunting antlers ** Mule deer
Prefer hunting*** Either/or
Last year I got a 4x4 white tail and this year I got a 3x3 mulie, within a 1/4 mile of each other. The mule deer has a stronger taste (not bad or gamey) just stronger. The white tails that I have gotten in this same area, eating the same thing as the mule deer taste much better.
If you want antlers than go for mulies. Bobby

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

I love 'em both...each is difficult and unique in it's own wat that makes me love hunting either species! JDinAB

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

I'd definately say the whitetail!!

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

whitetails by all means!

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

I've never hunted mule so I have to go with whitetail!

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

[/quote]

If you want antlers than go for mulies. Bobby
[/quote]

I have wondered about that. I agree here in Montana, it seems like mulies definitely have the antler edge. But based only on photos and tv, seems like a whitetail from east of here that is considered "decent" would have as big of a rack than a western muley that scores "decent".

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

Muley by far

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

I like them both, each bring their own challenges and rewards. If made to choose I prefer hunting whitetails. Taste no contest Whitetail gets the nod.

RE: WHITETAIL OR MULE?
 

we don't have mule deer here. I wouldn't mind traveling and trying my hand at it. I do really like hunting whitetails though.