I think he would score around 120. He is a nice buck but an 8 pt will have to have more mass to go over 130. A 130 8 pt usually looks bigger than a 140-150 10 pt. he is probably 4 years old. He is still a nice buck.
|
Hopefully, you will get him on camera next year, and can share the image with us. I would find it interesting to see his antlers in 2015.
|
those calling the buck in the 130's, 140's, and even a 150 compare the 2 pics, the top buck scores 126, horns are about equal except the top buck has a wider spread and more mass. you figure the top buck has 2" more spread, at least 4" more on main beam length, and possibly 2" on mass, your looking at approx. 118" in the bottom pic. RR |
Wouldn't body size factor in to the appearance of the rack size? Not sure what your deer weighs but just thinking a WV deer wouldn't be an accurate comparison to a Kansas deer based on the fact that i have always heard Kansas deer are heavy compared to the same age WV deer. Its all just my opinion but no way do I believe that second deer is only 118 inches. Guess I never will know
|
Originally Posted by grinder67
(Post 4181899)
Wouldn't body size factor in to the appearance of the rack size? Not sure what your deer weighs but just thinking a WV deer wouldn't be an accurate comparison to a Kansas deer based on the fact that i have always heard Kansas deer are heavy compared to the same age WV deer. Its all just my opinion but no way do I believe that second deer is only 118 inches. Guess I never will know
here is a link to some bucks that either barely made 125" P&Y min. or barely did not, look at the 130's and 140's in there http://forums.bowsite.com/TF/bgforum...orum=4#3086109 RR |
I know what it takes for 8 point to make 140's. I have a 142" 8 point on the wall(gross). And from the first and third picture of the original poster they are similar other than lacking some mass and some brow length.
|
|
Very nice deer rockport. And just a side note you could be the twin brother of a friend of mine here in Indiana. Every time I look at your avitar I think its him.LOL
|
Originally Posted by grinder67
(Post 4181944)
I know what it takes for 8 point to make 140's. I have a 142" 8 point on the wall(gross). And from the first and third picture of the original poster they are similar other than lacking some mass and some brow length.
|
Originally Posted by grinder67
(Post 4181949)
Very nice deer rockport. And just a side note you could be the twin brother of a friend of mine here in Indiana. Every time I look at your avitar I think its him.LOL
lol poor guy |
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:59 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.