I think that he could make the P&Y net score. I prefer the gross score also, it gives you the true story, P&Y and B&C don't see it that way though!

Johnny King would agree with you. :D

Newbie question here but what is P&Y and B&C?

P&Y is Pope and Young. It's the archery record book. A buck has to net 125 inches to get in as a typical. Not sure about non-typical.

B&C is Boone and Crockett. That's the record book for all methods of harvest (including roadkills and found deer). Their minimum is 170 inches for a trypical and 195 inches for a non-typical.

So, basically, I am asking if my buck will have more than 125 inches of antler after side-to-side deductions are subtracted due to asymetry.