johnandmare

Here is a picture of the buck we call Goliath. I have inserted a picture of a buck from last year. My husband and I think it is the same one - Goliath. He has gotten a lot wider, but the shape of the rack seems the same. I posted him in another thread wondering what he would score, but never asked if everybody agrees with us that he is the same one. He is the biggest buck we have seen to date here. Other than him, we have 2 forks, one is big enough to be called a 4 point, and a spike with about 10" spikes! That's another reason why we think he is the same guy, there are no other big bucks showing up. I know there could be more that we never see, they don't get big because they're dumb However, I have come to the conclusion that it is definitely Goliath.
Also, for you guys and gals that are good at scoring, what was he last year compared to this year - the consensus on this site is that he is between 115 and 120 this year. THANKS!!

texas8point

Could be......looks like summer and winter, rut and no rut times of the year. The antlers look allot alike.

johnandmare

Yeah, I agree, but my husband and some other folks say it's two different deer. IMO, the change of coat and the way they bulk up, completely changes the way they look, but I still believe it is the same rack, just bigger. I am very curious as to what the consensus will be. Hopefully people will answer.

timbercruiser

I think it is a different buck. Look at the right brow tine and the blurred photo buck seems to be a little longer. I don't think either one will make 115 inches tho.

arrow2512

i think it's 2 different bucks myself look at the fork on the left antlers on both deer there different .Just my guess

Tiereta

not the same buck

srwshooter

hard to say,but the buck in the first pic has a heck of a body.

shawnfogelman

Thats not the same deer.

Hunting Kuk

he looks the same to me IMO but i aint 4 sure

johnandmare

Someone mentioned that he is the same because of the markings around his nose, the triangle of black in the white. It does make sense. The other deeer I see around are all different around each of their noses, so it could be a distinghuishing characteristic.