the piebalds and albinos are truly something different and i think i might take the doe though i have never seen a 150class buck, though i have only been out and about for 2 seasons.
Also cardeer, i used your necklace this season and my first deer i ever got was a good 8 point buck weighing 160 field dressed. The deer saw me and about over the course of 45mins he moved inside the 25yard line and i got him. the strangest thing though, he seemed to be drawn to me, he was always moving slowly closer and closer, so i kept talking to him and finally he moved with in range. i tihnk i need more practice talking to him because it took me 45mins to get him to move 15yards closer.

propmahn
save the world, reload your brass

I'd buy an extra doe tag and if ethically possible, shoot both. The debate solved!
Visit My Hunting Page

Edited by - kshunter on 11/26/2002 23:09:56

I like kshunter idea, go with what your heart says

"ATTITUDE REFLECTS LEADERSHIP, CAPTAIN!"

Now if the 150 class buck was white or half/half then I'd say get him and put him on the wall. Dang, get him if he ain't white. Most people don't get the opportuntity to take a 150 class buck. As for the white doe, unless you don't have any meat in the freezer I'd say "NO" don't shoot her. I mean why would you want to shoot her just because she's white? Are you planning on tanning the hide? I have to agree with bionicrooster, that's gotta be bad medicine. It'll put a black cloud over you that you can't get rid of.

i would hope that situation would arise that both would come in front of me, but seeing as i alreaddy have a piebald spike id go for the 150class buck, last year i seen a piebald eight poitner that would go around 135 but sadly he died very soon after that lol white doesnt camo good in green honeysuckle

"She said if I hit that fishin hole today, she's be packin all her things and she'd, be gone by noon....I'm gonna miss her, when I get home."

id take the white doe...youve killed way bigger bucks...a white doe would make your room look great! ive always wanted a white deer myself...and if i every get the chance im taking the shot...its your choice....i already know what id do 7 yrs bad luck or not..

Well this would be a hard one. But i would probaly have to take the buck because i have never gotton a buck before but i have gotton 4 does. Although it would be nice to get the doe to match my dad's full albino buck mount.

If it were my choice I would choose the doe.150 bucks are not rare,but a white doe would be the trophy of a lifetime.

[Deleted by Admins]

Me I would take the doe NO DOUBT