Given equal opportunities, which would you try to harvest? It seems both are now moving on the trail in front of one of my stands on a bow only property. Both of their tracks are 95mm +. Also maybe some guess at what they would score and/or weigh on the hoof.
Deer A


Deer B


Deer B again


Also I'm wondering what is leaving these tracks on the trail - possibly a more formitable hunter? This track is slightly larger that my clenched fist (100-110 mm).

now that's a tough choice. from the pics i like deer b myself, but it would be a tough choice either way. need a new hunting buddy??

Deer B all the way!,and the tracks look like dog,i have the same thing on my property,strays..

I'm with ISD, deer B and a stray dog.
Both deer are awesome but if both were in front of me I would take B. Good luck with him.
Brandon

Holy cow !! If anyone from my state saw these guys they would cry. Deer b looks like he would weigh more and he has more mass to his rack. But then again, deer a is further away.

Whichever came out first!

deer B if I had my choice, but whoever came out first would be dead! I think it's dog tracks!

Thats a pretty tough choice but it looks like deer B has more mass to go along with the size so I would take him first...

i would try to get both of them. i'd shoot the first one i saw.

Deer B, and I would guess mountain lion due to lack of claw marks