Hey, for those of you who saw my post asking how one deer would score, I was wondering if you thought that this new buck is the same deer, or a different one. My optimistic mind wants me to say its different, but I wanted you guys' opinion.

1st deer




Here is another pic I just added to help with the profile view.
This is of the first deer, or at least the first set.

2nd Deer (new pics)

I say same deer or its his twin. Same genetics if not but I say the same...

Different deer....look at the curvature of theright antlers. The second buck has a distinct hook from the base to the G-2 (up, then out)while the first buck doesn't appear to have it (just out and up together). At least thats what it looks like to me. And look at the side views of each buck's left antler....the first buck's G-2 is longer than its G-3....the second buck...the G-3 is longer than the G-2. I say two different bucks.

Same deer...mainly judged by the brow tines...same lengths pretty much and also the left vs right side size...

SAME DEER...CAN TELL BY BROWS. mAIN BEAMS ARE THE SAME ALTHOUGH IT LOOKS DIFFERENT FROM THE ANGLES.

Same deer. Same left g-2.

same left g2 thats the distinctive point thatand the browtines

i would say same deer.

I say different deer - based soley on boredom and the brow tines

Also, the right mainbeam and G2 form a perfect V, not to mention same broes and left g2. Same deer.