I videotaped these two bucks a couple of weeks ago and took snapshots of the video. Sorry that they are not that good of quality but that is the result of a shaky hand and trying to find a good single frame. So, which one do you think is the better buck? They are both so different...

First...taller, more mass, extra brow tine...



Second...more width, longer G-3's...

I would say if you are going to hunt either of these deer I would choose the first one. He seems to be an older deer and has a ton more mass. The second deer if let go until next year will end up being a real hog with awide rack and alot more mass.

Buck number2 looks like he would score the best.

At first glance, I would say the second one...But then again I would be happy with either one.

The second, but the 1st one is also nice because it looks unique with the extra tine.

Yeah, I am not sure that I will be hunting either one of these - I think there might be a couple of bigger ones. I just couldn't decide which one I thought was a nicer deer nor could I decide how old they were. Thanks for the input!

Probly #2... looks likea better deer it has more spread and the tines are just as long.. Good luck with em!

The better buck will probably be the second one, if he has another year or two to mature.

I would take the second, more symetrical. Mass to me looks similar. Spread which is over rated but nice goes to buck #2. However if the first one offers a shot, he would get it also. Both are beautiful bucks you have a sweet place there.

the best one would be the one who walks in front of my stand during for the 2nd best would be the one who walks infront of my stand in gun