Do you guys think this is the same deer?

I think you have a few different deer there. Two with different size crab claws and the other seems to be a straight eight.

same deer to me..this could be argued indefinitely

I say 2 different bucks.

Definately different.

Blessings.........Pastorjim

Different for sure.

I see three different deer...

Cheers/bg

first 3 pics are same buck.. fourth and fifth appears to be the same buck however the 5th pics angle is poor for dicifering much rack detail and with it being 5 or 6 mins latter it is possible that it is a different buck. however because he appears to be turning to head down hill i think it is the same buck and he just stood there for a few trying to figure out the camera.

Different deer without a doubt.

first three are same deer with cool character, 4th picture is definitely different and i'd be 95% confident the 5th pic is a third deer.