HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Technical (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/technical-20/)
-   -   Walmart Arrows (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/technical/198140-walmart-arrows.html)

BowHunterJim 07-18-2007 07:47 AM

Walmart Arrows
 
I have 3 arrows from walmart and i can get 3 touching at 20 yards. I dont see the need to shell out 60 bucks for twelve when u can only shoot one at a time.

Just thought i would post this to show u that u dont neeed a top of the line arrows to get good groups.

P.S They also hang about 4" over my rest.

mobow 07-18-2007 08:37 AM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
Yes, you're certainly right, you can indeed get good groups with them. One thing to keep in mind about "Wal Mart" arrows though. They are typically rejects from the manufacturer and they sell them Wally World at a considerably reduced price. I've seen those arrows bend and break when shot. Be sure to check them often. ;)

BowHunterJim 07-18-2007 09:05 AM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
Yeah i check all carbon arrows before i shoot them. Haveing carbon splinters in my arm does not sound fun.

Roskoe 07-18-2007 08:38 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
I'm not a big Wal Mart shopper either, but I got some Carbon Express Terminator Hunters (camo) there awhile back and they shoot great! Bought a bunch more night before last. They are 31" long and weigh 407 grains without a point - but group very well and really quiet the bow down. I have shot several 2" groups at 40 yards with these arrows.

BowHunterJim 07-19-2007 04:16 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
yeah im goint to walmart to pick up 3 more so i can have 6 arrows then buy 6 muzzies for 29 bucks with 8 bucks shipping.

JNTURK 07-19-2007 05:16 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
i think the arrows are just fine...brother and i shoot the carbon wolverine (even cheaper arrows)...shot well enough for me and you can get them regular price for about $3 an arrow...and later in the year the clearance them out and i have gotten some as low as $2 an arrow...crazy cheap

BowHunterJim 07-20-2007 02:45 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
Yeah bought 3 more arrows today at 4.50 a arrow. They changed the cock vance color toblack from white. Yeah didn't shoot them and am getting them cut tonight.

Roskoe 07-20-2007 02:52 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
Are the ones you got the Terminators - 31" long and marked 6075?

BowHunterJim 07-20-2007 04:13 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
No I got the ThunderStorm form Carbon Express. They did have them there though. Not sure of the price.

Madjac20 07-20-2007 05:21 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 

ORIGINAL: JNTURK

i think the arrows are just fine...brother and i shoot the carbon wolverine (even cheaper arrows)...shot well enough for me and you can get them regular price for about $3 an arrow...and later in the year the clearance them out and i have gotten some as low as $2 an arrow...crazy cheap
I'm not a big fan of the "evil empire", but I bought up as many of the Carbon Express Terminator Lites (4560's 29" long,I believe) at the end of last season from WalMart at $3 a pop. Shoot great and don't see any problem with them.

Roskoe 07-20-2007 05:43 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
OK - only reason I asked is that I noticed your bow is 50 lb. If you are cutting them down, the arrow is going to get "stiffer" and may not work as well in a 50 lb. bow.

BowHunterJim 07-20-2007 06:40 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 
yeah the 6075 means the weight that the arrow can be used with 60 lbs to 75lbs right?

MDBUCKHUNTER 07-20-2007 09:46 PM

RE: Walmart Arrows
 

ORIGINAL: BowHunterJim

yeah the 6075 means the weight that the arrow can be used with 60 lbs to 75lbs right?
Not always!

I hunt with a 70lb bow. If I were to use my GT 5575's I have laying around I would be extremely underspined. I had to upgrade to GT 7595 to gain proper spine and a better shooting arrow.

I try to tell everyone that manufacturers recommendations are just that....recommendations. You really need to look into your specifics of your own setup to find proper spined arrows. (try the On Target 2 software)

You will never, ever see me buying arrows from Walmart. Ever since I saw a gentleman weedthrough all the arrows and make himself his own "perfect" dozen in a box, thus leaving all the crappy arrows behind for other archers to purchase, I refuse to give Walmart the time of day. (especially since the manager was standing right next to him!)

brandonxc 10-29-2009 12:54 PM

i recently got some carbon wolverines 6075's from walmart. they shoot great, i dont see the point in spending $70+ in arrows. ecspecialy for people on much more of a budget. they allow you to buy 1,2,3 or 50 arrows, not just 12 like you get from most anywhere else.

itsslow98 10-29-2009 08:18 PM

I agree, i just dont see how much of a difference a walmart carbon arrow could be from a 25 dollar carbon arrow with a brand name. maybe its just me but i cant bring myself to outfit an arrow that costs a total of 35 bucks+ with a broadhead. Ill keep shooting my 6075s from walmart till they let me down.

brandonxc 10-30-2009 04:49 AM

how long does walmart normally stock bow supplies? arrows specifically

The Rev 10-30-2009 04:56 AM

They are certainly not cheaper for me, I can get arrows from a sponsor dirt cheap. I did buy a few different arrows from there this year only to see which would fly better with my recurve. If you notice the price they are more expensive to buy only one.

The Rev 10-30-2009 04:59 AM


Originally Posted by brandonxc (Post 3489296)
how long does walmart normally stock bow supplies? arrows specifically

They start stocking just before bow season, and when they sell out the don't re-stock.

brandonxc 10-30-2009 08:07 AM


Originally Posted by The Rev (Post 3489304)
They are certainly not cheaper for me, I can get arrows from a sponsor dirt cheap. I did buy a few different arrows from there this year only to see which would fly better with my recurve. If you notice the price they are more expensive to buy only one.

lol i wish i was sponsored. but if you break down lets say $60 for 12 arrows thats $5 an arrow, and you have to drop $60 at that time. where with the walmart arrows you can buy 1-all they have, just get what you need, or slowly build up, its easier for me to get 3 each week than get 12 all at once. For me its a big budget thing, if i had more money then sure i would shoot nicer arrows, but these do good for me and fit better in to what i can afford to spend. I know i cant be the only one out there on a budget.

bigcountry 10-30-2009 10:02 AM

You can get a dozen much cheaper usually than buying singles.

I buy good shafts for 55-70 dollars. And put them together myself. If I was to buy separately, it would be a fortune.

I will never understand how people can put 1000 dollars in a bow and then want to shoot cheap ole arrows and wonder why its hard to tune.

Kid 10-30-2009 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by mobow (Post 2149132)
One thing to keep in mind about "Wal Mart" arrows though. They are typically rejects from the manufacturer and they sell them Wally World at a considerably reduced price.

Did wal-mart let you in on this little secret? Hard to believe this is true with liability laws in our lawyer driven society being what they are. Wal-Mart doesn't make arrows, so it is hard to believe ANY arrow maker would allow their "rejects" to be sold by anyone, period. The better price surely comes from Wal- Mart's buying power, not a manufacturers willingness to sell rejects and risk their reputation and million dollar judgements. :action-smiley-099:

brandonxc 10-30-2009 10:37 AM

the carbon wolverine 6075's are made by carbon express, and like kid said, no one would sell reject arrows to anyone

BleedinBuck 10-31-2009 01:04 AM


Originally Posted by Kid (Post 3489689)
Did wal-mart let you in on this little secret? Hard to believe this is true with liability laws in our lawyer driven society being what they are. Wal-Mart doesn't make arrows, so it is hard to believe ANY arrow maker would allow their "rejects" to be sold by anyone, period. The better price surely comes from Wal- Mart's buying power, not a manufacturers willingness to sell rejects and risk their reputation and million dollar judgements. :action-smiley-099:

i completely agree with you there as for buying my arrows i get them from my local shop where he does everything like cutting them putting feathers and whatnot on them and it does cost a lil more but most of us hunt as a recreation and not the sole source of food so if you cant afford to shoot dont but i will never buy cheap arrows from walmart:bash:

brandonxc 10-31-2009 04:42 AM


Originally Posted by BleedinBuck (Post 3490248)
i completely agree with you there as for buying my arrows i get them from my local shop where he does everything like cutting them putting feathers and whatnot on them and it does cost a lil more but most of us hunt as a recreation and not the sole source of food so if you cant afford to shoot dont but i will never buy cheap arrows from walmart:bash:

so what your saying is, dont shoot a bow or enjoy the sport unless you can afford to spend big money arrows.

brandonxc 10-31-2009 05:06 AM

i love how people think to do or enjoy or to be successful you have to have the best of everything. camo jackets and pants $100-150+ each. boots for $150+ Are you kidding me? what im saying is that it does NOT matter what you spend, cause when it comes down to it, we are all doing what we love.

BleedinBuck 10-31-2009 09:14 AM


Originally Posted by brandonxc (Post 3490312)
i love how people think to do or enjoy or to be successful you have to have the best of everything. camo jackets and pants $100-150+ each. boots for $150+ Are you kidding me? what im saying is that it does NOT matter what you spend, cause when it comes down to it, we are all doing what we love.

i do not think nor do i have the best but one area i will not buy the cheap stuff is on my bow i've got over 1300 & alot of time in my bow so i will not buy cheap arrows in my eyes kinda like buying a corvette then putting cheap gas in it.

brandonxc 10-31-2009 10:27 AM


Originally Posted by BleedinBuck (Post 3490497)
i do not think nor do i have the best but one area i will not buy the cheap stuff is on my bow i've got over 1300 & alot of time in my bow so i will not buy cheap arrows in my eyes kinda like buying a corvette then putting cheap gas in it.

but if the arrows are made by the same company, probably coming off the same line and getting a differnt logo on it, who's to say they are "cheap" yes they cost less, but it doesnt mean they are cheap/worthless

superstockbigblock 10-31-2009 05:34 PM

I think what he is saying is the quality is lesser, they are the price for a reason. It is like you said...and it is true, I hunted cheap walls camo for years, it is good stuff, warm, noisy, and loose fitting. I didn't hunt rainy days, and I got cold in a treestand. I now have better. I never had the money then for anything better, and no range finder and I missed deer. You have to get what you can afford. Shoot something solid with the cheap arrow, I tried one from walmart, and it broke when it hit out of my 82nd. Granted I was testing it on a post, but my Maximas won't break, niether would my Gold Tip Pro Hunters, sure I might pull the insert out, but the arrow isn't broken. If you don't do a lot of shooting, have a lower powered bow, and you can get away with it and it floats your boat, buy them. I won't, more for you.

Ed McDonald 10-31-2009 06:44 PM


Originally Posted by mobow (Post 2149132)
Yes, you're certainly right, you can indeed get good groups with them. One thing to keep in mind about "Wal Mart" arrows though. They are typically rejects from the manufacturer and they sell them Wally World at a considerably reduced price. I've seen those arrows bend and break when shot. Be sure to check them often. ;)


This is BullCrap ! If you don't like walMart fine but ......... you are saying that Carbon Express sells rejects through WalMart ! So are the Remington rifles , shotguns junk also ? Are their tools and appliances seconds ? get real !!!
I have shot the Carbon Express Terminators for target practice and they shoot great . I hunt with a heavier arrow .

brandonxc 10-31-2009 07:56 PM


Originally Posted by Ed McDonald (Post 3490924)
This is BullCrap ! If you don't like walMart fine but ......... you are saying that Carbon Express sells rejects through WalMart ! So are the Remington rifles , shotguns junk also ? Are their tools and appliances seconds ? get real !!!
I have shot the Carbon Express Terminators for target practice and they shoot great . I hunt with a heavier arrow .

well according to some people if walmart has them then remington must have rejected them. i also shoot a mossberg atr 100 .30-06 that came from walmart. and guess what it shoots every time, perfectly. its just stupid that people think their high dollar gear is what makes or breaks a successful hunt, when in all honesty it dont mean crap.

nodog 11-01-2009 11:42 AM


Originally Posted by brandonxc (Post 3490979)
well according to some people if walmart has them then remington must have rejected them. i also shoot a mossberg atr 100 .30-06 that came from walmart. and guess what it shoots every time, perfectly. its just stupid that people think their high dollar gear is what makes or breaks a successful hunt, when in all honesty it dont mean crap.

It's not like that. What you bought was a heavy arrow and when tested for straightness and spine consistancy the range is as great as allowed, whatever that is.

A heavy slower arrow will be more consistant and great if your good at ranging things. If a person wants an arrow to cover more of a range with one pin then a lighter faster arrow is needed and that means more expensive.

I'm all for your attitude about the cost of things however sometimes more expensive does mean crap.

Done it. I know what expensive as well as Walmart arrows are like. Set a bow up with both and you'll find the Walmart arrow dropping way out of the kill zone long before the more expensive arrow.

Walmart doesn't sell rejects although since Sam died I wonder. Hunting section in my local Wally world sucks anymore.

mauser06 11-01-2009 12:48 PM

so nodog, the higher the arrow price the lower the arrow weight?????? :eek2: i think that was terribly phrased...or, i hope so....

my arrows aint walmart arrows but they are heavy...im having trouble making sense of your post...i dont know what arrows are on walmart shelves, but i'll almost guarentee that "walmart arrows" are not all real heavy...heck i doubt any of them are rated over 10gpi...my terminator selects are 10.6...so i must got ripped off by paying more for a heavier arrow?!?!

i personally dont shoot walmart arrows...

i actually do shoot CX terminator XP Selects..which are pretty reasonably priced...but, actually have some of the best specs on the market..and are some of the heavier carbons on the market..

for that price, i doubt they are fletched great..i doubt the inserts are glued great...and i'd definently love to see them thrown on a scale and weighed out..and love to see the spine consistancy as well...

SwampCollie 11-01-2009 01:45 PM


Originally Posted by Kid (Post 3489689)
Did wal-mart let you in on this little secret? Hard to believe this is true with liability laws in our lawyer driven society being what they are. Wal-Mart doesn't make arrows, so it is hard to believe ANY arrow maker would allow their "rejects" to be sold by anyone, period. The better price surely comes from Wal- Mart's buying power, not a manufacturers willingness to sell rejects and risk their reputation and million dollar judgements. :action-smiley-099:


Well... carbon express and easton tell me this...

They do the same thing with Bass Pro and Cabelas lines of arrows. Not always... but frequently.

Lets take easton (or specifically Beman) for example... did you know that easton really only makes a couple of different types of arrow shaft in the carbon hunting line???

Now, nobody sets out to make 'rejects', but they do happen, and because of the way carbon arrows are made (rolled from a single sheet like the paper stick of a lollipop), they are very difficult to control in the spine, thickness and straightness departments. So lets say that Beman sets out to make ICS Hunter Elites. They are the highest price, and most consistant at +/- .001 in straightness. Next you have your gold standard ICS Hunter at +/- .003. Followed by your Bowhunter, which is .006 in straightness. What they do with the ones that fall outside of those parameters is beyond me. But take your arrows like the Carbon Raiders they sell at "Richards" Sporting Goods... they are just ICS Hunter Elites that got REJECTED.

That doesn't mean that they are not safe... not at all.... it simply means that from a quality control standpoint, they didn't make the grade. What you are paying for when you pay for high end arrows is for someone to sit down and test each one with lasers and benders and holy water and whatever else to ensure that they are as closely matched as possible (and our own bigcountry will tell you that sometimes these QC folks come to work with hangovers... or perhaps still drunk.... as the holy water doesn't always take). Easton X10 Pro Tours are matched +/- .001 for THE WHOLE DOZEN... meaning if you were to lay them end to end... the whole lot would be that straight.... these are olympic competition quality arrows and you don't find them in wal-mart.

All that these arrow companies are doing is finding a way to make their money back on their 'rejects'.... rather than just throwing them out, they are selling them at a reduced price.

That is how business works... no different with jewelry, gun stocks, funiture etc etc... anytime you have a material or product that you simply will not know how the quality is until its done.... you get various lines (or grading if you will) of product.

SwampCollie 11-01-2009 02:10 PM


Originally Posted by Ed McDonald (Post 3490924)
This is BullCrap ! If you don't like walMart fine but ......... you are saying that Carbon Express sells rejects through WalMart !

I don't know about him, but yes that isEXACTLY what I am saying. See my post above.




So are the Remington rifles , shotguns junk also ? Are their tools and appliances seconds ? get real !!!
I have shot the Carbon Express Terminators for target practice and they shoot great . I hunt with a heavier arrow .
That I highly doubt... at least as far as the firearms are concerned... I don't know about tools or appliances.

I do fully suspect that you will often find lower quality grades of wood (or should I say basic grades)... I don't think that Remington is going to do wal-mart any favors when it comes to product... it will be to standard, that is for sure... but don't expect anything above and beyond... of course you knew that when you walked into wal-mart in the first place.

You are going to have to use some business common sense here..... but the reason behind this lies in simple economics and business practices. Wal-Mart is what my professors in college used to call 'The 800 Pound Gorrila'... you'll remember the proverb that the 800# Gorilla can sit wherever he likes.

Wal-Mart's buyers will go to Remington or whatever company and say..... 'I'll take 5 million units of X product at Y price or I won't take a damn one.' Remington has the job of first finding out if it is even feasable... and then to deliever said product. No MAJOR (and I mean that by volume)company is going to say no to Wal-mart when they want to buy THAT MUCH product...

So, Remington or any company for that matter, has basically three choices...

1) it can reject wal-marts proposal outright and basically say no to a potentially HUGE HUGE profit (wal-mart isn't exactly going under in these tough economic times you know),this isn't really an option, because to ignore the cash cow that wal-mart often is... you wouldn't be in business or have a job at said business very long if you turned away potential new customers

2) it can offer wal-mart an inferior or 'rejected' model at a much reduced price (often under a differnet brand name as to not undercut its own QC standards... (ie Dewalt and Black and Decker, or ICS Elites and ICS Bowhunters), understand that it is of course in line with some standards of quality control... but they are much much looser... and all firearms have to meet a LOT of standards before they are sold to consumers or...

3) it can design a new, lower price point, model specifcally for box stores.... such as the 770.... or 710.... or the Stevens Model 200... Stoegers model 2000... etc etc.... and open itself up to a totally new, lower margin but higher volume sector of the market.

That doesn't mean that its inferior from a function standpoint... but it is made from 'inferior' materials and to much less rigorous standards than mainline or high end goods are. You cannot really expect to be getting all the quality of a custom shop 700 when you buy a 770 for $394 and change can you? Remington would go bust! No company (not even wal-mart) expects their suppliers to sell to them at a loss... thats just not how business works.

PS: And for what its worth... yes... I work in the outdoors, archery and firearms industry for a living... and we do pretty well I think. :cool2::patriot:

superstockbigblock 11-01-2009 05:35 PM

SwampCollie you are correct, and that is how walmart does business, they name the price because they buy a lot. I work in the food industry, and that is no different, either sell the product to them, or lose the shelf space, or lose out on making it to a competitor who will gladly have the business.

nodog 11-02-2009 06:37 AM


Originally Posted by mauser06 (Post 3491527)
so nodog, the higher the arrow price the lower the arrow weight?????? :eek2: i think that was terribly phrased...or, i hope so....

my arrows aint walmart arrows but they are heavy...im having trouble making sense of your post...i dont know what arrows are on walmart shelves, but i'll almost guarentee that "walmart arrows" are not all real heavy...heck i doubt any of them are rated over 10gpi..i personally dont shoot walmart arrows...

.

last ones I bought were close to 12, there were a carbon composite ie heavier. They had lighter ones as well, can't remember the brand. Arrows I shoot are 9 or under. That adds up in drop and speed. If your good at ranging, no problem.

Most come full length and set to go so your shooting the arrow at it's heaviest. People who buy ready made arrows typically buy them because they don't make there own and cutting them down requires a saw so they're going to be shooting the full boat.

When I had one a few years ago I commented to my daughter that my bow could shoot any arrow well and grabed the Walmart arrow, shot from where I shoot and watched the arrow impact below the kill zone.

I like the arrows, they were well made and had an excellent camo finish to them, shot well and I could get one 24/7/365 in a place I'd likely be often.

Sure you can get lighter arrows cheaper but the lighter arrow needs to be much more consistant in spine and weight to group well, the heavier arrow does not. The requirements for the lighter arrow almost always means your going to pay more.

The Walmart arrow was a little heavier than an FMJ. Shot some last year, nice arrow but they were heavy. Too heavy for me. Brother likes the Beaman MFX. That's a great arrow but it's on the heavy side as well.

This conversation has given me something to think about, the way I'm shooting this year at game I should switch to a heavier one, can't seem to stop shooting high. For some reason I'm more invisible to game this year than ever, they come right up to me. Had a doe the other day 10 yards away looking right at me, eye level for the hunter she was sure was much farther away. She had no idea how close she was. Not used to these close shots. Missed a nice buck that day that did the same thing. Went right over his back. A Walmart arrow would've been perfect. Like being hit with a slug. :)

nodog 11-02-2009 06:50 AM

The question is why were they rejected, I say it isn't because of structural quality, it's because of strick spine and weight requirements which I don't believe is all that good reguardless of what the manufacturer has said they are. I've never heard of a walmart arrow exploding, but I've heard of plenty others. Had a GT XT do it on me about 4-5 years ago and when I contacted the retailer I was told they'd had more complaints of that shaft doing that than any other for that past year.

nick_bleuer76 11-02-2009 07:10 AM

Try at 60 yards....

JoshKeller 11-02-2009 07:11 AM

what pound draw weight is your bow? With those thunderstorms being only spined to 50 pounds, you may find that those muzzys fly completely different.

Gundeck 11-02-2009 11:30 AM


Originally Posted by brandonxc (Post 3490292)
so what your saying is, dont shoot a bow or enjoy the sport unless you can afford to spend big money arrows.

Yes, what he is saying is if you can't drive a Ferrari, you shouldn't be on the road. Guess he doesn't drive, because I am sure he can't afford those arrows AND a Ferrari.

:poke:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:46 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.