Brass Life
12-29-2008, 08:37 AM
#1
Guest
Posts: n/a
Brass Life
Anyone read handloader? They have an article that is real interesting. They were trying to find the most accurate load possible for a 308win with all components available.
Anyway, they tested the brass life for like 10 different pieces of brass. It appears Norma and remington came out on top for lasting 18 shots before failure FL sizing them. Nosler and Fed came in last failing around 10 shots or less. Federal is not a huge surprise. But surprised remingtoncame in so well.
Anyway, they tested the brass life for like 10 different pieces of brass. It appears Norma and remington came out on top for lasting 18 shots before failure FL sizing them. Nosler and Fed came in last failing around 10 shots or less. Federal is not a huge surprise. But surprised remingtoncame in so well.
12-29-2008, 09:12 AM
#3
Guest
Posts: n/a
RE: Brass Life
But another thing that really surprised me is with the federal brass, they were able to get 10 firings without the primer pocket being so loose it wouldn't hold a primer. usually for me, the failure on federal is the primer pocket.
The failure on this test was case stretch near the rim.
The failure on this test was case stretch near the rim.
12-29-2008, 12:36 PM
#4
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Orange county, NY
Posts: 2,949
RE: Brass Life
I believe Rem brass has thicker walls than winchester( never used federal or anything other than rem and win) I weighed both and the rem cases are heaver by a couple grains.
You would think that the rem cases can be loaded more Xs but Ive found that winchester cases are easier to full length size after 2-3 loadings.
You would think that the rem cases can be loaded more Xs but Ive found that winchester cases are easier to full length size after 2-3 loadings.
12-29-2008, 02:58 PM
#5
Typical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 604
RE: Brass Life
Interesting post. It is good to see an actual evaluation tosee thruthe hype.
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
12-29-2008, 06:54 PM
#6
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 493
RE: Brass Life
WhenI order brass it is allways Lapua, I did the Norma thing once and when I tried Lapua it was a little tighter in the weight issue, and quiet a bit tighter in the price issue!
I would love to subscribe to Handloader Magazine, but they just ask way too much for a 6 issue per year rag.
BTW guys, I'm probably going to be in Philly.,next week to do a little repair work on some rails we have built for the city, if some of you live in that area and would like to meet this sweet old boy, abbr(SOB) just pm me and asap I'll forward where I'll be staying, who knows we might even down a few cold ones!
I would love to subscribe to Handloader Magazine, but they just ask way too much for a 6 issue per year rag.
BTW guys, I'm probably going to be in Philly.,next week to do a little repair work on some rails we have built for the city, if some of you live in that area and would like to meet this sweet old boy, abbr(SOB) just pm me and asap I'll forward where I'll be staying, who knows we might even down a few cold ones!
12-29-2008, 07:37 PM
#7
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location:
Posts: 1,408
RE: Brass Life
I haven't used anything but Winchester, I had too many reliable sources disparage Remington to me to bother trying them. So no personal experience. I neck size for my bolt guns and only FL for my Garand. Only on the second reload for the Garand cases so no info there, but I'm on reload #8 with hot loads in my 300WM and I haven't had to throw a case yet and accuracy is still great.
12-29-2008, 08:58 PM
#9
Guest
Posts: n/a
RE: Brass Life
ORIGINAL: Scott Gags
Interesting post. It is good to see an actual evaluation tosee thruthe hype.
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
Interesting post. It is good to see an actual evaluation tosee thruthe hype.
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
12-29-2008, 09:39 PM
#10
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: ****ifornia
Posts: 5,052
RE: Brass Life
ORIGINAL: bigcountry
First was Norma, then Remington, then Lapua. Next Winchester, then Federal, and surprisingly Nosler came in dead last.
ORIGINAL: Scott Gags
Interesting post. It is good to see an actual evaluation tosee thruthe hype.
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
Interesting post. It is good to see an actual evaluation tosee thruthe hype.
What I would like to see is a side by side comparison of full length sizing vs neck sizing. I am using Lee Collet dies andam curious if therehas been any data collectedto compare the two. I also wonder if the articles comparisonwas based on neck sizing would therankings change much.
Your timing isgreat because I wasgoing to orderLaupa brass with a Cabelas gift certificate and thought the Laupa would pay off in the long run but now think I may just stick with my remington brass.
PS: If you dont mind checking How did Laupa Fair?
I bet if they were running hot loads it might have turned out different...?