You are correct , but RSB ,BTB and Livbucks insist that ARs did in fact increase rack sizes of 2.5 + buck. And ,as I am sure you recall ,Alt said we we likely be seeing more and larger buck than ever before.

I see more and larger buck i know that its because they are allowed to age a extra year or two not because they magical have bigger horns

bowtruck: we are just waisting our time with BB! He doesn't believe!

BB,Alt was delusional with many of his claims but I still have yet tosee where he claimed the average size of 2.5 year old bucks would increase.

If your are hasn't been subjected to significant HR , you would in fact be seeing more buck, but that si not what has happened over the vast majority of the state.

but, please explain how you know the 2.5+ buck are bigger now that the 2.5+ buck we harvested before ARs?

That is because you keep wearing those PGC blinders. The claim that we would see ," more and larger bucks" means just that. Check with any english teacher regarding the sentence structure and meaning.

I believe ARs allows a higher percentage of 1.5 + buck to live one more year. When the PGC releases data that shows the average 2.5+ buck is bigger than before ARs , then I will believe ARs increased the rack size of 2.5 + buck. until then I will believe the results form Miss. Texas and Dr. Kroll's research which all indicates ARs will reduce the average rack size.

Never said 2.5 are bigger now then before ars
you said



bluebird2

titleAndStar(1925,0,false,false,"","")
Non-Typical


[align=center][/align]
Posts: 1925
Joined: 4/4/2008
Status: online

















window.google_render_ad();

You are correct , but RSB ,BTB and Livbucks insist that ARs did in fact increase rack sizes of 2.5 + buck. And ,as I am sure you recall ,Alt said we we likely be seeing more and larger buck than ever before.



ok you said alt said we we likely be seeing more and larger buck than ever before

I said i do because they are allowed to age a year or two instead of being shot at 1.5

You may not realize it , but when you made that claim you said you are seeing larger buck than before ARs. that means the 2.5+ buck you are seeing now are bigger than the 2.5+ bucks you saw prior to ARs.

i see you are twisting what i say so rather than get into a flam war with you i have to decline and post my thoughts on other threads

sorry bluebird not tonight