Anyone care to guess at the weight of my Brother's 2008 PA buck? I have the dressed weight and will post it later after some guesses.

It dressed out at 173 with a live weight of 215, am I close? [8D]

165 dressed 185 live

Hatchet Jack

I'm gonna guess that it dressed 189.

I'd say dressed it's a bit over 200 lbs... like 205. He's a brute, nice buck. Congrats.

170

I think I am going to come in too low, I just noticed how large that front shoulder is. I'm fine with the racks I get each year but I really really really want to shoot a buck that dresses over 200 sometime soon. Hopefully I get that bad boy in Everett, PA next year because where I hunt in WV just doesn't have those huge bodied deer running around.

154 lb. 200lbs, now that is funny. all these 200lb pa deer showing up dressed. what is the pa record weight deer? lmfao

180 is my guess. nice deer congrats

Looks to be smaller bodied than mine. I would guess dressed 155 - 165. Petro - why do you doubt 200 lb PA deer? Granted - they are far and few between. In my 40+ years I've maybe seen 5 that went over 200. Mine being the last one.