Go Back  HuntingNet.com Forums > Regional Forums > Northeast
 PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING >

PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Community
Northeast ME, NH, VT, NY, CT, RI, MA, PA, DE, WV, MD, NJ Remember, the Regional forums are for hunting topics only.

PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Thread Tools
 
Old 02-11-2007, 05:23 PM
  #41  
Giant Nontypical
 
BTBowhunter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: SW PA USA
Posts: 7,220
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Maybe we could call in Mythbusters
BTBowhunter is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 05:29 PM
  #42  
Host of Hosts
 
PABuck_HNTR's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Erie, Pennsylvania
Posts: 5,780
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

That first picture of the doe with one leg looks like a Florida deer. Very small body size. Is that supposed to be a Pa deer? And I agree that I see alot of deer that look like the second picture especially in early spring.

PABuck_HNTR is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 06:10 PM
  #43  
Nontypical Buck
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Slower Lower Delaware 1st State
Posts: 1,776
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Yea MythBusters - you got there #
AJ52 is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 06:23 PM
  #44  
Typical Buck
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 584
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

When did they start the deer herd reduction?
Which time? They started herd reductions in this area back in the 1930s but it got derailed after just a couple of years due to all the yammering to stop killing does.

There have been countless attempts to get the deer herd in balance with the habitat since then but every time herd reduction has got on the right track that yammering started again.

The most recent herd reduction attempt for this area started in 2000.

And if that many was to weak to give birth and you knew that winter took a toll on the deer in them 2 seasons why did the PGC still gave out those large numbers of doe tags?
The deer didn’t have enough food through the winter for all of them to survive or to be healthy enough in the spring to produce healthy fawns that could survive after birth. When that is occurring the deer and their food supply are sending you a very clear and convincing message. That message is that there are too many deer for the habitat and food supply.

So your answer to not having enough food to support the existing deer numbers is to harvest fewer deer and keep more through the winter to exist on less food per deer?

Unreal!!!!!!

That has been the very problem that leads to the deer population collapse in the first place.

And how do you know them deer died at the lastfew weeks of winter. And shouldn't this been documented along with pictures. How is anything to be done properly or changed to correctif events like thiese are not documented. On a large scale you speak of, it should of been documented. Any specialist in a field would document these things. True?

It was documented. It was documented and recorded when I walked the same wintering grounds drainages for the exact same distances that I had been walking during the previous years at the end of the winter snows. I know those deer were dead because I looked at them and broke the femur bone, when I could find it, to determine if that deer died of malnutrition or not.

Here are the results of my finding per year along the same 4.7 mile stretch of three separate wintering grounds drainages. I just pulled my copies of those reports out of my file cabinet.

Year………………dead deer

1997………………..1
1998………………..0
1999………………..1
2000………………..1
2001………………..2
2002………………..1
2003………………..3
2004……………….10
2005……………….4

The simple fact is that we had mild winters through the 1990’s that allowed the deer herd to grow beyond what nature would normally have allowed. People got spoiled expecting those favorable deer recruitment conditions to last forever but that all ended with three consecutive years of no mast crop combined with harsh winters.

Protecting more deer just means the scavengers have more food cleaning up the dead or weakened deer throughout and following a harsh winter.

The only way to have more deer for the long term into the future to balance the deer herd with the habitat until the habitat recovers enough to support more deer. You have to have the habitat (that means food) before you can have more of any species. That is one of nature’s laws, not mans and man can’t change that no matter how much he wants too.

How did they elk do up there? I would think worse because they eat more than the deer?
The elk did just fine because elk have longer, more powerful legs so they just continued to move through the deep snows even after the deer got locked into wintering grounds. The elk are grazers so they would go out in the open areas, dig the snow off the ground with a front leg and eat the grasses that have little winter nutritional benefit for deer. Deer are browsers through the winter and need to have sufficient browse in the low lands wintering grounds during winters with deep snow.

There are a lot of major differences between elk and deer and their feeding preferences, which is how they can live on the same range without adversely affecting the food supply for the other.

R.S. Bodenhorn




R.S.B. is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 06:39 PM
  #45  
Giant Nontypical
 
BTBowhunter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: SW PA USA
Posts: 7,220
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

RSB, you are to be commended for your infinite patience in explaining that which should not need any explanation. You obviously make your job much more than law enforcement. There aren't enough out there like you.

you are a credit to your profession, even if you didnt want us to hunt that last 1/2 hour
BTBowhunter is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 06:53 PM
  #46  
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 189
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Year………………dead deer

1997………………..1
1998………………..0
1999………………..1
2000………………..1
2001………………..2
2002………………..1
2003………………..3
2004……………….10
2005……………….4
These numbers seem to be reversed from what you think they would be.
More deer higher number of deaths. But as the herd declines the number increases. Could it be that the larger number of deers made it easier for the rest of the deer and weaker ones to travel and forage for food? The stronger ones pack the trail down for the others to follow. Deer use to yard up in groups of 20+ in bad weather now lower that to3 to 5deer and their chance of survival has gone done. Could this be the cause of more deaths?


There are a lot of major differences between elk and deer and their feeding preferences, which is how they can live on the same range without adversely affecting the food supply for the other.

georgepoker is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 07:07 PM
  #47  
Nontypical Buck
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: PA
Posts: 1,149
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

RSB,did you do this survey after the 93-94 winters?Back to back bad ones as I remember.
germain is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 07:25 PM
  #48  
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: PA.
Posts: 5,195
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter

RSB, you are to be commended for your infinite patience in explaining that which should not need any explanation. You obviously make your job much more than law enforcement. There aren't enough out there like you.

you are a credit to your profession, even if you didnt want us to hunt that last 1/2 hour
why dont you just give him a big kiss,i had people that commented at work like that and they always went up ladder..jeez
sproulman is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 07:33 PM
  #49  
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: PA.
Posts: 5,195
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter

Ihave seen deer that looked pretty close to that in the ANF and on the game lands near East Branch Dam along the Shawmut RR Grade. i will grant you that it has been at least 15 years ago though. I havent been in that area for that long but I have seen some pretty skinny and small deer in the ANF more recently but thats been more than 5-6 years ago.


Sproul, where can we find those pictures? Do they really exist?
i asked you to give me a pm with your address and i would mail it to you..

then you ask me if they exist, nothing like be a little TRUSTING.. like i said, i am no FIBBER..

the picture was taken by AP..and no rib showing on those deer,big turkey ,i mean big turkey playing with a few big doe..

the picture was in THE EXPRESS,feb10/11 th paper, lock haven, pa.page A3.www.lockhaven.com ....phone 1-800-941-3231...fax 570-748-1544..
sproulman is offline  
Old 02-11-2007, 08:13 PM
  #50  
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location:
Posts: 576
Default RE: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING

Deer kill planned for western Pa. government campus 02-02-2007 By DAN NEPHIN Associated Press Writer PITTSBURGH (AP) A federal agency will kill about 200 deer at a government campus that the Pennsylvania Game Commission said is overpopulated with starving and diseased deer a situation partially brought about by post-9/11 security measures.
Agents from the United States Department of Agriculture will shoot the deer within the next few weeks, said Harris Glass, state director of the USDA's wildlife services in Pennsylvania.
The 237-acre site about 12 miles south of Pittsburgh houses the Department of Energy's National Energy Technology Laboratory and offices of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Mine Safety and Health Administration.
Before the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, gaps in the facility's fencing had allowed the animals to move in and out, said Samara Trusso, a wildlife management supervisor for the Game Commission. But repairs afterward reduced deer movement and their population increased far above the recommended densities by Game Commission officials.
``We never had this problem occur prior to this century,'' Bob Reuther, a Department of Energy spokesman, said Friday.
The department had about 50 to 60 deer killed at a 140-acre facility in Morgantown, W.Va., last year for the same reason, he said.
Two surveys found about 200 deer at the Pennsylvania campus, Trusso said. Only about 65 acres on the campus are suitable for deer enough to support two to four healthy deer but even that habitat has degraded, she said.
Glass and Trusso said the deer are starved and diseased, but keep breeding.
``Basically, they've asked us to remove everything,'' Glass said. ``You look at the deer and you'll understand.''
Employees have been feeding the deer either for enjoyment or because they recognize the animals are unhealthy, which added to the problems, Trusso said Friday.
The Game Commission discourages people from feeding wildlife. Doing so can concentrate animals, making it possible for disease to spread more easily.
``In the short time, it absolutely can keep the deer just healthy enough to continue to breed at their regular levels,'' exacerbating the overpopulation problem, she said.
People often feed wildlife inappropriate food, leading to malnourishment, she said.
``If you and I eat popcorn every day, eventually, we would start to show signs of malnourishment,'' she said.
Feeding corn, a popular item, is particularly bad because deer, like cows, are ruminants, and have stomachs with multiple chambers for digestion, she said. Microbes inside aid digestion, but too much corn can kill the microbes, she said.
Game Commission staff found the carcass of one deer that died of starvation, but had a stomach full of corn, she said.
Typically, Glass said, a team consisting of a sharpshooter, a driver and a person using night vision and heat-detecting equipment will humanely euthanize the deer at night, when few people are around. Only trained USDA employees are used, he said.
Hunters could not be used because of security concerns.
``It needs to be a very controlled situation,'' Glass said. ``It's not hunting. It's a tool.''
T_in_PA3 is offline  


Quick Reply: PGC SAYS DEER ARE STARVING


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.