HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Northeast (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast-26/)
-   -   Total kill count for PA (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast/124682-total-kill-count-pa.html)

Legacy357 12-12-2005 09:46 AM

Total kill count for PA
 
I want PA hunters to post their deer kills for the 2005 seasons. I am just trying to get this thread going because of the total lack in reports from PA. So if you shot anything in PA, please post as follows. Thanks:

Deer: Buck (points) or Doe
Weapon used: Bow, Crossbow, Muzzleloader, Rifle
WMU Killed In:
Date:
# of Deer Seen:

Deer:Doe
Weapon used: Bow
WMU Killed In: 5C
Date: 10/01/2005
# of Deer Seen: 3

dvdegeorge 12-12-2005 09:59 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
[ol][*]1 buck 8pt[*]1doe[*]Rifle[*]11/28/2005(opener)[*]WMU2A[*]25 deer seen[/ol]

deerslayer223 12-12-2005 11:58 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1. buck 4pt(yes i could legally shoot it i have the disabled permit to hunt from a vehicle)november 30th rifle
2. Doe october 21 rifle
3. WMU 2C somerset county
Very poor deer sightings. only about 20 deer seen all season from archery and rifle seasons combined. Only 2 bucks seen both small.

PaJack 12-12-2005 12:20 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Buck - 7pt
Rifle
WMU 3B
12-02-05
9 deer seen

Doe
Handgun
WMU 3B
12-09-05
5 deer seen

fatsbucknut 12-12-2005 01:46 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
2 Doe
Bow
WMU 4-E & 4-D public land
Atleast 40 in archery


rybohunter 12-12-2005 02:06 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
I shot 6 deer, 5 does, and a 12 pt. 3 in 2D, 3 in 2B. 4 with a bow, 2 with a handgun during regular gun season. Some days I saw a lot of deer, some days I didn't see any.

PA Bow/Flinter 12-12-2005 03:56 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Button Buck
Bow
1B
11/7/05
I've seen about 40 deer in 1B and also saw 9 deer in 2G when I was hunting bears.
Thats 49 on the year so far...and prolly more on the way.
*At least 10 of those are bucks for sure.

PABuck_HNTR 12-12-2005 05:17 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Button Buck
Bow
2F
11/12/2005
Saw total of 5 deer in archery season in 4 days afield 1 small spike 3 doe and the button buck
Saw total of 7 deer 1st day rifle 1 buck not legal to shoot saw 1 doe second day... and 1 doe on private land ...1st friday.first and second saturdays saw 5 doe total and a 5 point.

20 deer in 9 days of hunting.....Not real good

Maybe I'll get lucky in second season archery. If I'm brave enough to battle the elements.

Four Sox 12-12-2005 05:43 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
deer killed: none
bow\rifle
6 deer all year
2E and 5b


Obviously not a good year here!!!

Speedmaster 12-12-2005 05:47 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1. 8-pointer
Bow
3D (Public Land)
10/01/2005
Saw total of 12 deer including the one I got during archery season and I hunted at least 20 days during the season!
Only seen 2 during rifle season! And I was out every day but 2!
Still have 2nd part of archery! ButI really doubt I'll even see anything! But I'll still be going out!

BarnesX.308 12-13-2005 06:41 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Deer:Doe
Weapon used: Rifle
WMU Killed In: 3B
Date: November 29
# of Deer Seen: Between0 and 12a day - depends, every day was different. I saw plenty around the cabin after shooting hours.


frocb 12-13-2005 06:42 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
8 point buck
11/12/2005
Bow kill
5a
Seen 5 deer in early season archery

1 doe
12/10/2005
Rifle
5a
I was out the first day and both Saturdays, seen 13 deer all together.

bigdog02 12-13-2005 06:49 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Reporting for my father:
Deer: Buck (8 Points)
Weapon used: Rifle
WMU Killed In: 4A
Date: 12/3/05
# of Deer Seen: 33 total that day (several were repeats I am sure, being run around the property)


patrkyhntr 12-13-2005 08:12 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Filled three tags. Eight point on the second Thursday of rifle season and two does, also during rifle season. All three were hog fat.
Didn't see as many deer as last season, but that was what I expected.



White-tail-deer 12-13-2005 11:44 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Deer: Buck, 9 Point
Weapon: Rifle
WMU: 5B
Date: 11/29/05
No. of Deer That Day:4 Buck, 2 Doe

Deer: Doe
Weapon: Rifle
WMU: 5B
Date: 11/30/05
No. of Deer That Day: 28 Doe

Joe D. 12-13-2005 11:49 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Deer:Doe
Weapon used:.308 Winchester - 150Gr. Barnes X bullet
WMU Killed In: 3B
Date: November 28
# of Deer Seen: Anywhere's from 1-10 whenI hunted. Seen more during archery season, but that's normal. Would have to sayit's been apositive year for me as far as deer sightings go.

Mystro 12-13-2005 12:20 PM

Best Year of my hunting career! (but does'nt reflect how the woods were.)
 
I had the best Hunting ever!!! I hunted almost every day of archery and rifle season. I saw next to nothing except what I shot. My success is by no mean a true reflection of howlow the deer encounters were.(HORRIBLE, PITIFUL, etc...)
All my trophys were taken in the Extended Bear and rifle season.
1 Bear in extended bear season (1st day ofbuck/extended bear)

1 Large 5 yr old 8-point buck in rifle (last day of rifle)
1 Large 6yr old buck that lost its horns a week or so earlier and had to be tagged a doe (last day of rifle).

(see pic!)


snipehunter 12-13-2005 03:59 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 

ORIGINAL: rybohunter

I shot 6 deer, 5 does, and a 12 pt. 3 in 2D, 3 in 2B. 4 with a bow, 2 with a handgun during regular gun season. Some days I saw a lot of deer, some days I didn't see any.
not to start anything or nothingtoward rybohunter but can anyone else see maybe why no one is seeing deer this year with all of the bonus tags it is not hard to see where the deer have gone what ever happened to the ole` days of one buck or doe per year you remember folks two weeks for buck and three days for doe i stomped all over the clearfield area to see 3 deer. 5 years ago it was a different story. i feel that this time of "if it is brown it is down" thinking will have all of us going to another state to hunt. (rant done stepping of of my soap box thanks)

Pa Trophy Man 12-13-2005 04:28 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1.5yr olddoe
Killed in WMU- 1A
Weapon:Compound Bow
# of Deer- 2


3.5yr old doe
Killed in WMU-5B
Weapon:Compound Bow
# of Deer- 2


2.5yr old buck - 7 scoreable points 12 1/8th inch spread
Killed in WMU- 1A
Weapon: .308 Winchester
# of Deer-5



3 for Me, all of which were killed in State Parks. Overall i saw less deer in general, however i saw an enourmous amount of bigger bucks which is fine by me. I didn't keep an exact count throughout the whole season except the days i shot deer. Overall, i would guess around 25-35 doe(which is down from about 50-60 from last season) and 15 different bucks including the one i shot the first day of rifle. It was a banner year for larger bucks, as i saw three bucks during archery that im sure would make Pope and Young with 2 others that would have been very close.


Legacy357 12-14-2005 06:24 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
keep um coming:D

PABowhntr 12-14-2005 07:30 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1.
8 point buck
Compound Bow
4C (Public Land)
10/1/05
6 other deer seen that day, 3 buck and 3 doe

2.
Adult Doe
Rifle
4C
12/10/05
8 other deer seen that day, all anterless


villeman 12-14-2005 10:06 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
8pt
12/3/05
WMU 4A
2 other deer seen

adult doe
12/10/05
WMU 4A
2 other deer seen

ragin cajun 12-14-2005 01:20 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
8 point buck 184 lbs. dressed
crossbow
5D
10/12/05

Harvested 2 Doe
1 crossbow, 1 shotgun
5D

I am generally seeing at least a deer every time I hunt in 5D, but numbers are lower than last year
I hunted opening day of rifle in 4B - saw one doe running

PA Hardwoods 12-14-2005 04:19 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1. 2 1/2yr old Doe
Flintlock (opening Saturday of Early Muzzleloader
4D (Rothrock State Forest with DMAP Tag)

2. 6 1/2yr old Doe (Aged by Game Commission Biologist)
Rifle (opening Day of Rifle Season)
4D (Juniata County)

early in 12-15-2005 06:19 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
The Pa season is not over yet, there is still the late archery season!

Legacy357 12-16-2005 06:30 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
yea i know.........and i plan on killing my buck in second archery in 5C :D

OConnorPAhunter 12-17-2005 06:02 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Doe
Rifle
3C
First Saturday

I saw 11 other deer in rifle season

aldo88 12-17-2005 08:50 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
1. Button Buck
2. Rifle
3. 2f
4. Saw 4 deer the first day and then the one I shot a week later. Seeing deer isnt like it used to be. They need to cut out on the bonus tags and go back to the 3 days of doe.
Plan on going back out for second season using a bow.

BTBowhunter 12-17-2005 05:07 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Deer 1 10 pt buck and three does

the buck and two of the does with the bow. One with the rifle

All killed in 2B

Saw too many deer to count

Here's the buck





germain 12-17-2005 06:24 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Nice one BT.

Don't shoot doe in our area
didn't kill any buck
4 deer sighted in archery season
0 deer sighted in rifle season

This was in good thick habitat in WMU 2E withplenty of food.I knew the populations were low going in but was hoping my scouting would pay off.It's really tough hunting in an area with deer numbers so low.I'm hoping to find a lease in my area but that's not easy.Soon it might be time to take the dive and head out to the southwest and stay in a motel.That sucks when you have so much money and hard earned time in a cabin but if you want to continue hunting deer these a days ya gotta do something.
Out of state might be another option.

HUNGRYEYE 12-18-2005 06:23 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
[>:]Get the check stations going . Untill they do that and get the right cout on what's being killedand stop the guessing game.

ilbback 12-18-2005 06:41 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Weapon Archery...9 point 11/11/05
Rifle doe 12/5/05
Area: 3C
Deer sightings: In archery 6-18/day Hunted the last week of archery with another guy and we saw total 17 different buck between the two of us.

Rifle season: I hunted with the bow the first day and saw 6, ironically the only shot I had was at a small legal buck. We hunted the 2nd week of rifle. We saw buck every day including 4 shooters of which we got one. Saw several smaller bucks and quite a few doe. It was funny because reports of "my hunting neighbors" for the first week indicated that there were no deer left. Very few sightings and little sign. After it snowed on Friday (after they all left) There was deer and deer sign everywhere.



germain 12-18-2005 07:46 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
That's a dandy back.

Legacy357 12-23-2005 08:56 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
back to the top.........keep um coming guys

BTBowhunter 12-23-2005 04:32 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
nice buck Illbback!!!

kevster10p 12-23-2005 05:29 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
any from 2g

PA Bow/Flinter 12-23-2005 08:13 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
GOT MY BUCK!!!
Took him on a special hunt on the Pymatuning Resovoir.
5 pt 115 lb buck......he was trailing a doe!
12/22/05
WMU 1A
This was the 28th deer of the day.....saw around 60 or so total. That place has way too many deer!!



brknarrow 12-23-2005 09:40 PM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
7 point buck, first day of archery
I do not shoot Doe. Period !
There is enough people in the area that I hunt, that are trying to wipe them out.

xtrembowhntr 12-24-2005 12:07 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
buck: 10pt
bow
2b
nov.2nd.


doe
inline .50 cal. muzzleloader
1a
nov. 28th.




Gr8ful Deer 12-27-2005 09:49 AM

RE: Total kill count for PA
 
Deer Shot: 0
Weapon Used: 30-06 & .50 cal Flintlock
WMU #: 3B
Days Hunted: 5
# of deer seen: 1-5 per day


From my logbook:

Opening day of rifle, I passed on a 6 point at 20 yards (got so close because of the heavy fog.) This buck hung around my treestand for over 45 minutes before it was chased away by some approaching noisy hunters. It was the only deer I saw that day.

2nd day of regular firearms season, I saw 0 deer.

First Friday of rifle season, I passed on a 5 pointer thatwas within 45 yards of my treestandfor at least 20 minutes. Only deer I saw that day.

First Saturday of rifle, I saw 1 doe.

Yesterday, I hunted flintlock, and I saw 12 deer (9 of them while driving to/from) our hunting spot. I could have shot a large bedded deer from ~50-60 yards that I walked up on while putting on a small silent mini-drive to my Dad along with my borther.I could not seethe deer's head to tell if it was buck or doe before it spooked and bolted.It was definitely a VERY LARGE deer, and I supsect it may have been a big buck.

Sadly, I saw almost as many coyote and bobcat tracks as deer sign while walking the woods.

The deer population is patheticly low in 3B this year.

- Gr8ful


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:18 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.