Which do you perfer

I've rattled in numerous bucks with the bag. Don't really see the reason to haul out the extra mass of full antlers.

I have both and prefer a rattle box instead. For me, it is just confidence. When I hunt with my dad... he claims it sounds fake but, buck usually come running.

Thats what my dad told me is that it sounds fake but i dont see the reason in carrying those horns if you dont need to

This is a tad off-topic, but what are the best methods for using either one? I have tried with both and didn't attract jack.

If rattling on the ground I will only use the real thing. You can not only rattle but rake leaves and trees using real antlers.

i use bag cant make myself cut of horns to at least a euro mount