Woolywag

anybody here hunting w/ a 450? just wondering how they perform on moose/deer

Shootstuff4570

i dont hunt with a 450 but i hunt with a 45-70 and that works great so i imagine that the 450 should perform somewhat close to the 45-70

JeffS

I use one for Hogs and they work great. Basically they are are hot loaded 45/70. When you hit something w/ them it doesn't go far. I haven't used it on deer yet though it should work great for deer or moose. The only limitation is you need to keep your shots to 200 yards or less because the bullet really drops fast past 200 yards.

SWAMPMAN

Woolywag,
No moose, but they'll darn sure lay out a big swamp hog. Awesome results on pigs, they just fall over. Haven't lost one yet.

DM

One of my brothers isn't into balistics at all!!! He's NOT "one bit" interested in any of it!! He buys a gun, buys some ammo for it, sights it in, and goes hunting!

He shot a LOT of deer with a 444 Marlin and liked it! He said it killed deer quite good! He still has it.

Then he bought a 45/70 and after shooting 5 or 6 deer proclaimed it a DUD!!! It kills them, but too slow for his taste!! He sold it!!!

Now he has a 450 Marlin and has shot about 15 or more deer with it. He really likes it, and said it really does the job on them!!!

Perasonally, i've not used one myself,

Drilling Man

bigcountry

DM, I got myself a 45-70 last week, and only reason I picked that, I knew I could juice it up to close to 450marlin. If I didn't reload, I would have picked the 450marlin. I guess he was shooting the slow stuff.

James B

For the reloader there is nothing that the 450 Marlin or 444 Marlin can do that the 45-70 can't do. If you don't reload then one of the others may be better.

max the dog

An unexpanded .450 has three times the frontal area of a .270. It's also got some weight behind it to carry it through bone and tissue that would stop a smaller round. Combined, it's heck of a lot of hurt.

DM

Aaaaaaaww lets see...., that's .277 x 3 = .831" . That is it was where i went to school!! A .450 Marlin bullet is HOW big????

No matter, there's just a LOT more to it than "frontal area" and "bullet weight" that determines what happens to an animial when the bullet hits it!!!

Drilling Man

longrifle1000

DM, I was thinking the same exact thing. All I could think of was, HUH? LOL Maybe math has changed a lot since we've been in school. Unless he meant the actual tip of the slug? I don't know, my brain hurts. LOL