whats the difference?
#21
RE: whats the difference?
ORIGINAL: leben_sie_gut
In that picture, is that an exit wound visible behind the foreleg? That's a helluva hole from a .243.
In that picture, is that an exit wound visible behind the foreleg? That's a helluva hole from a .243.
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location:
Posts: 1,813
RE: whats the difference?
JMO, but, it seems to me that if you've got a kid shooting, he's going to be a lot more likely to flinch and gut shoot a deer with a .30-06 than he will with a .243.
All of them are a better choise than a .243 and won't kick the sh** out of a smaller person..
DM
#23
RE: whats the difference?
ORIGINAL: DM
Are you saying you "have" to jump from a .243 all the way to an 30-06?? What happened to the 260 Rem.? 7-08, 257 Roberts and several others???
All of them are a better choise than a .243 and won't kick the sh** out of a smaller person..
DM
JMO, but, it seems to me that if you've got a kid shooting, he's going to be a lot more likely to flinch and gut shoot a deer with a .30-06 than he will with a .243.
All of them are a better choise than a .243 and won't kick the sh** out of a smaller person..
DM
But according to Chuck Hawks' tables, .260 and 7-08 pack about 50% more recoil than the .243. And, I disagree that the Roberts is a better choice than the .243. With factory loads, the .243 delivers more energy on target, with less recoil in a lighter rifle (again according to Hawks' tables). The standard .243 even has more energy than the .257 +P's.
[blockquote]Ballistics for .243, .257 Roberts, and Winchester's .257 Roberts+P
Velocity (ft/sec)
Cartridge TypeBullet Muzzle 100 200 300 400 500
Remington® Express®100 PSP CL 2960 2697 2449 2215 1993 1786
Remington® Express®117 SP CL 2650 2291 1961 1663 1404 1199
Winchester +P 117 gr Power Point 2780 2411 2071 1761 1488 1263
Energy (ft-lbs)
Cartridge TypeBullet Muzzle 100 200 300 400 500
Remington® Express®100 PSP CL 1945 1615 1332 1089 882 708
Remington® Express®117 SP CL 1824 1363 999 718 512 373
Winchester +P 117 gr Power Point 2009 1511 1115 806 576 415 [/blockquote]
#25
RE: whats the difference?
All my deer have been killed with a 243 and I am 36.. Anyone who says a 243 is not a good round for a kid is absolutly incorrect.. Mine was good for me when I was 14 and is good for me now.
#27
RE: whats the difference?
ORIGINAL: Beware_of_Dawg
also, second question... I have a .22 LR, do the .17 HMR's fit this rifle?,
also, second question... I have a .22 LR, do the .17 HMR's fit this rifle?,
#28
Fork Horn
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 169
RE: whats the difference?
I am missing something here. This thread went from .222 and .223 to .243 thru .30 06? Hmmmmmmm. I also must have missed that day in class when we were covering the 1000 and 1500 foot pounds of energy needed to efficiently harvest animals. I wonder how much energy a compound bow generates? Is that weapon capable of efficiently killing a animal? Who developed these rules on bullet energy and where are they published?
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location:
Posts: 1,813
RE: whats the difference?
And, I disagree that the Roberts is a better choice than the .243. With factory loads, the .243 delivers more energy on target, with less recoil in a lighter rifle (again according to Hawks' tables). The standard .243 even has more energy than the .257 +P's.
I've harvested deer with a .243, so i know how they work, and if everything is right they work ok... 257 works better if everything isn't right though...
That's why i always say the 257 is better...
DM
#30
RE: whats the difference?
ORIGINAL: Slow Burn
I am missing something here. This thread went from .222 and .223 to .243 thru .30 06? Hmmmmmmm. I also must have missed that day in class when we were covering the 1000 and 1500 foot pounds of energy needed to efficiently harvest animals. I wonder how much energy a compound bow generates? Is that weapon capable of efficiently killing a animal? Who developed these rules on bullet energy and where are they published?
I am missing something here. This thread went from .222 and .223 to .243 thru .30 06? Hmmmmmmm. I also must have missed that day in class when we were covering the 1000 and 1500 foot pounds of energy needed to efficiently harvest animals. I wonder how much energy a compound bow generates? Is that weapon capable of efficiently killing a animal? Who developed these rules on bullet energy and where are they published?
http://www.huntingmag.com/guns_loads/all_012505/
I suspect if you try google, you could find a lot more.
Arrows kill in a different way than bullets. Less about energy transfer, more about slicing and dicing. And, I would argue that it's not nearly as "efficient."