HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Firearm Review Forum (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/firearm-review-forum-33/)
-   -   Ed Brown Rifles? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/firearm-review-forum/247088-ed-brown-rifles.html)

jeepkid 05-24-2008 03:45 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 

ORIGINAL: salukipv1

thanks for the link, Jeep,

checked it out, looks awesome, I think if that barrel were 22-24" I'd be very interested. I'm really liking that Kimber...


Just curious, but why would you want a longer barrel? It's not going to pick up a bunch of velocity with the longer tube...

oldelkhunter 05-24-2008 06:03 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 

Neither the Ed Brown, Remington 700, or Browning are CRF. Remington is importing a mauser clone that is but I'm pretty sure it's not Stainless. The Kimber Talkeetna sounds perfect. That is if your willing to spend Ed Brown type money.

Out of the three the ED Brown is the only one that features CRF. It's not CRF in the traditional sense with the claw extractor just a modified push feed CRF.

salukipv1 05-24-2008 06:36 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 
Jeep,

In my mind I had 24" as the ideal length, so 22" would work as well, but now at 21" is 3" in my book. I hear you on the velocity though, what do you think 21.5 vs 24" difference would be? 50-75fps?

Anything against that Kimber?

jeepkid 05-24-2008 10:13 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 

ORIGINAL: salukipv1

Jeep,

In my mind I had 24" as the ideal length, so 22" would work as well, but now at 21" is 3" in my book. I hear you on the velocity though, what do you think 21.5 vs 24" difference would be? 50-75fps?

Anything against that Kimber?
I don't think with a .375 H&H the barrel length would be a huge factor with velocity. It seems like velocity vs. barrel length varies with every caliber/cartridge so I'm not sure. If I was hunting something that could eat me (what .375's are usually used for) then I think I would want a shorter/easier to point barrel. My .375 H&H barrel is 24", but thats all it is is a blank barrel, I need to find a donor action to finish it.

Not sure about the Kimber, it seems like most of them are either great or terrible. Might also check out CZ.

HEAD0001 05-25-2008 03:00 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 
Kimber?? Terrible?? I do not think so.

I own and have owned over a dozen Kimber's. I have not been disappointed in one yet. I have shot dozens more with zero problems. IMO when some one shells out big dollars for a firearm they expect it to perform magic. A lot of shooter's who buy a more expensive rifle have high expectations, but do not have high capabilites. And if you do not have the ability to take advantage of a quality firearm, then a lot of people will blame the firearem(for their inadequacies).

The Ed Brown rifle is a high quaity piece. I have handled a few of his works, and have shot one(never owned one). They would be a great firearm to own, but just a little too pricey for me. you are paying a little extra for the name. Tom.

jeepkid 05-25-2008 03:25 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 

ORIGINAL: HEAD0001

Kimber?? Terrible?? I do not think so.

I own and have owned over a dozen Kimber's. I have not been disappointed in one yet. I have shot dozens more with zero problems. IMO when some one shells out big dollars for a firearm they expect it to perform magic. A lot of shooter's who buy a more expensive rifle have high expectations, but do not have high capabilites. And if you do not have the ability to take advantage of a quality firearm, then a lot of people will blame the firearem(for their inadequacies).

The Ed Brown rifle is a high quaity piece. I have handled a few of his works, and have shot one(never owned one). They would be a great firearm to own, but just a little too pricey for me. you are paying a little extra for the name. Tom.
I don't own a Kimber, so I'm only saying what I've heard/read. It seems the Kimber of Oregon rifles were pretty good, but now the ones made in New York aren't the same quality.

WhitetailsInc.info 05-25-2008 08:19 PM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 
I have never heard a person who actually owned a Kimber complain about thier performance.

oldelkhunter 05-27-2008 11:29 AM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 

have never heard a person who actually owned a Kimber complain about thier performance.

Then I guess this will be the first time for you.:D BTW which Kimber? the Oregon models haven't been made in almost 20 years

WhitetailsInc.info 05-28-2008 07:28 AM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 
My response was directed to the Yonkers guns. I don't know anyone with the Oregon versions.

oldelkhunter 05-28-2008 08:01 AM

RE: Ed Brown Rifles?
 
My "Yonkers" gun a 84m in 7mm-08 went back for stock work, the stock warped and was hitting the barrel. I sent it back and got back a new stock,new triggerguard/floorplate assembly . Their customer service is fast and very good but I can see a lot of faults on the ones sitting on my dealers shelve.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:54 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.