.30-06 vs. .338 win mag vs. 300 win mag
#81
Spike
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
If you load, it really opens up many choices. I want to hunt deer with an Enfield, and have well made .303 Brit I can. .300 Win handloads are half the price of your 06 factory. Someone wants to use a Carcano and can load for it, fine.
#82
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 1,834
Likes: 0
#87
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 2,186
Likes: 0
From:
I own and shoot a rifle in each of these. I know squat about clean killing any game larger and tougher than a 300-400 pound feral pig. I hunt white tail deer in SE Alabama, and have hunted them a good deal recently in Arkansas and Texas. I have made several trips to eastern Montana chasing mule deer.
So - here's what I do know. I took the 300 Win. to Montana on a few mule deer hunts. I use a hand load - 180 gr. Game King and another using 200 gr. Nosler.
I am what I'd call an accomplished marksman by any means. I shot at and clean killed mule deer from about 225 yards out to about 400 yards. With the 300 Win. Mag. and the practicing I did, this was a rather easy deal to pull off under the field conditions I was faced with.
As for the 338 Win. Mag., this rifle beats my bu%% at the range. After about 40-60 rounds, I have had enough. I have never used it in the field. After testing several factory rounds, I settled on a particular Federal Premium load. l tried it at 100-200-300-400-500 yards. The load was zeroed at 200. At 500 yards, managing the drop became a real issue for me. But frankly I have not yet spent enough time at the range to make any realistic evaluation of this round at that distance. I do plan to hand load for it in the future. The cost of factory stuff is killing me !!!
Bottom line from a big game "know nothing" .... if I were going to try to kill a critter that could kill me back, I'd tote the biggest diameter, and hardest hitting round of the 3. Obviously the 338 Win. Mag.
So - here's what I do know. I took the 300 Win. to Montana on a few mule deer hunts. I use a hand load - 180 gr. Game King and another using 200 gr. Nosler.
I am what I'd call an accomplished marksman by any means. I shot at and clean killed mule deer from about 225 yards out to about 400 yards. With the 300 Win. Mag. and the practicing I did, this was a rather easy deal to pull off under the field conditions I was faced with.
As for the 338 Win. Mag., this rifle beats my bu%% at the range. After about 40-60 rounds, I have had enough. I have never used it in the field. After testing several factory rounds, I settled on a particular Federal Premium load. l tried it at 100-200-300-400-500 yards. The load was zeroed at 200. At 500 yards, managing the drop became a real issue for me. But frankly I have not yet spent enough time at the range to make any realistic evaluation of this round at that distance. I do plan to hand load for it in the future. The cost of factory stuff is killing me !!!
Bottom line from a big game "know nothing" .... if I were going to try to kill a critter that could kill me back, I'd tote the biggest diameter, and hardest hitting round of the 3. Obviously the 338 Win. Mag.
#88
I own and use a 338WM for elk. So far, it has performed superbly with 220 and 250 grain bullets. I would feel quite comfortable using it on bears as well. I own and use a 270 for deer and antelope. It works great on both. I have friends and relatives who own and use 30-06 and 300WM on elk and deer. I have personally seen both of those calibers work just fine on both. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the 3 and plan to acquire the other 2 for further "field testing." The bottom line is get what you can comfortably shoot, practice a lot and enjoy the hunt.
#89
Typical Buck
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 579
Likes: 0
From:
My vote would be for the 338 Win Mag. I'm a handloader so with the components available it is a great cartridge that can be loaded with 160-185 gr. pills for deer, use a 210 for elk, a 225 for moose, & a 250 gr. for any bear in North America. I've taken deer & hogs with 180 NBT @ 3100 fps out of a Ruger 77MKII & it puts em down in a hurry. I've worked up a good load with a 250 gr NPT but have only used it on 1 boar and as usual 1 shot and the hog dropped in its place. Was a Texas heart shot and it came out the front end from the back end.
#90
for deer, using 130 grain nosler ballistic tip reloads which I have worked up over the years.
Shot placement is paramount no matter what you shoot. I will hold
off until I have good shot placement, any good sportsman will. Only
a hard up slob won't.
As for .243 don't like them , seen to many wounded deer shot with
em , in the hands of a expert they are great but who can boast
they are a expert.
For big game, bear, moose ect. I use a wsm and always wait for
good shot placement.
Remember , these animals bleed and feel pain, so do it right the
first time.


