Excalibur Phoenix VS TenPoint Titan HLX
12-01-2009, 12:16 PM
#1
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location:
Posts: 295
Excalibur Phoenix VS TenPoint Titan HLX
Im getting an crossbow for christmas and I pretty much have it down to an excal or an tenpoint. I want to know the main difference between an recurve and an cam, do i have to unstring the excalibur when im not hunting?
12-01-2009, 01:53 PM
#2
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: No.MN
Posts: 1,053
Of the three I own, including one fast compound, the Phonex is the bow I usually pick up to hunt with. Simple to maintain, easy to **** and un**** and accurate to a fault. And at around 300 fps it's much easier on strings, arrows and target, yet has more than enough umpf for most NA game.
Perhaps this will convince you: " Once again Excalibur proves its industry leading accuracy by winning all three legs of this years IBO Triple Crown 3D championship. Excalibur shooter Kenny Barr also won the prestigious Worlds 3D Championship. In all of the first 3 legs Excalibur topped the charts with 3 of the top 4 shooting Excalibur crossbows. Leg 1 was won by Roy Meditz shooting an Excalibur, Leg 2 was also won by Roy Meditz. Leg 3 was won by Tim Tasker shooting an Excalibur crossbow."
BTW, check out the Ibex, same great bow but with a neat thumbhole stock.
Last edited by Cossack; 12-02-2009 at 05:51 AM.
12-02-2009, 04:47 AM
#3
Fork Horn
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 186
Just so happened you're talking about my favorite bow. The Phoenix is wider than the TP but much simpler and hassle free. You don't have to unstring either but you can let down the Excal with a simple rope ****er when finished hunting, instead of shooting an arrow at a stump or target. And you can change strings to reserve without using a press, just use a simple stringer. There are no cams, no cables to relpace, puch less a cabale slide.
Of the three I own, including one fast compound, the Phonex is the bow I usually pick up to hunt with. Simple to maintain, easy to **** and un**** and accurate to a fault. And at around 300 fps it's much easier on strings, arrows and target, yet has more than enough umpf for most NA game.
Perhaps this will convinve you: " Once again Excalibur proves its industry leading accuracy by winning all three legs of this years IBO Triple Crown 3D championship. Excalibur shooter Kenny Barr also won the prestigious Worlds 3D Championship. In all of the first 3 legs Excalibur topped the charts with 3 of the top 4 shooting Excalibur crossbows. Leg 1 was won by Roy Meditz shooting an Excalibur, Leg 2 was also won by Roy Meditz. Leg 3 was won by Tim Tasker shooting an Excalibur crossbow."
BTW, check out the Ibex, same great bow but with a neat thumbhole stock.
Of the three I own, including one fast compound, the Phonex is the bow I usually pick up to hunt with. Simple to maintain, easy to **** and un**** and accurate to a fault. And at around 300 fps it's much easier on strings, arrows and target, yet has more than enough umpf for most NA game.
Perhaps this will convinve you: " Once again Excalibur proves its industry leading accuracy by winning all three legs of this years IBO Triple Crown 3D championship. Excalibur shooter Kenny Barr also won the prestigious Worlds 3D Championship. In all of the first 3 legs Excalibur topped the charts with 3 of the top 4 shooting Excalibur crossbows. Leg 1 was won by Roy Meditz shooting an Excalibur, Leg 2 was also won by Roy Meditz. Leg 3 was won by Tim Tasker shooting an Excalibur crossbow."
BTW, check out the Ibex, same great bow but with a neat thumbhole stock.
12-03-2009, 04:42 AM
#4
Spike
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: SW Ontario
Posts: 7
Quote from Bill Troubridge owner of Excalibur, from the Excalibur forum
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:18 pm Post subject:
After decades of dealing with tens of thousands of crossbows I am of the opinion that it's marginally better to unstring at least between seasons, but I'm too lazy to bother fooling with the string and taking off the dissipator pads. I don't believe in the "do as I say, not as I do" system of advise, so our official policy is that you don't need to unstring as long as the bow is not stored in a very hot environment. Please note however that a short stay inside a closed vehicle parked in the sun during the summer can destroy a set of strung limbs.
Quoting myself
For the long term crossbow success and enjoyment
-I would stay away from the wheels and cables. May have problems sourcing cables after a few years.
-You need a press to change strings/cables on most compound crossbows. Hard to do field changes if required
-More mechanical moving parts to fail over time.
-Check length of warranty, Check country of origin
-Check your game laws for specific requirements, lenght of draw. poundage etc
-Be practical, don't get caught up in the "Cool" factor
-Last but not least -Don't buy until you try if shop won't let you shoot it, go some where else.
I'm biased though, I have a 150 lb recurve crossbow bought new 21+ years ago. Lots of hunting with just string changes over the years. It broke the front leg of one deer as the arrow exited the deer, never found the arrow. I would recommend anyone of the Excalibur bows, I just bought a 2009 Exocet 200 and am quite happy with it, son is getting old enough to hunt, hes going start buy using the old dependable 21+ year old Wolverine.
Czy Horse
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:18 pm Post subject:
After decades of dealing with tens of thousands of crossbows I am of the opinion that it's marginally better to unstring at least between seasons, but I'm too lazy to bother fooling with the string and taking off the dissipator pads. I don't believe in the "do as I say, not as I do" system of advise, so our official policy is that you don't need to unstring as long as the bow is not stored in a very hot environment. Please note however that a short stay inside a closed vehicle parked in the sun during the summer can destroy a set of strung limbs.
Quoting myself
For the long term crossbow success and enjoyment
-I would stay away from the wheels and cables. May have problems sourcing cables after a few years.
-You need a press to change strings/cables on most compound crossbows. Hard to do field changes if required
-More mechanical moving parts to fail over time.
-Check length of warranty, Check country of origin
-Check your game laws for specific requirements, lenght of draw. poundage etc
-Be practical, don't get caught up in the "Cool" factor
-Last but not least -Don't buy until you try if shop won't let you shoot it, go some where else.
I'm biased though, I have a 150 lb recurve crossbow bought new 21+ years ago. Lots of hunting with just string changes over the years. It broke the front leg of one deer as the arrow exited the deer, never found the arrow. I would recommend anyone of the Excalibur bows, I just bought a 2009 Exocet 200 and am quite happy with it, son is getting old enough to hunt, hes going start buy using the old dependable 21+ year old Wolverine.
Czy Horse
12-07-2009, 11:24 AM
#6
Spike
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location:
Posts: 76
Ive been under the assumption that my tenpoint is the best there is great performance, great customer service, great manuverability while hunting and most of all great bang for the buck, shooting a 425 grain bolt my hlx shoots 308 fps, i dont think a recurve can match that.Excalibur's are great but dont overlook a T.P. they are awesome crossbows, no "wishing" i bought anything else...............
12-07-2009, 12:13 PM
#7
Spike
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 47
im with speedball on this one. i work in a sports shop that sells crossbows and the ten point is the preferred x-bow, and on top of that, the HLX is the top seller. the ten point has excellent customer service and the limbs are guaranteed for life. the advantage to the ten point is that its assisted drawing mechanism is in the butt stock. that means nothing to forget at home. i will admit, the only draw back to the HLX is that compound x-bows are noisier than recurves, but the compounds tend to be faster. a solution to this problem is ten points silencing kit. but the ball is in your court, and i can guarantee you wont be disappointed with either
12-07-2009, 05:30 PM
#9
Spike
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1
I shoot a Ten Point GT Curve and the HLX. One could not ask for better performance with either. I have not shot any Excaliber products, but based on testimoney from many users they seem to be first rate also.
As with many products today, if you have an opportunity to try both brands you will be better able to decide what works best for you! A decision between either of these brands will be a winner I am sure!
For me, I am not gonna try to fix or improve on something that I am totally satisfied with--- and that is Ten Point!
As with many products today, if you have an opportunity to try both brands you will be better able to decide what works best for you! A decision between either of these brands will be a winner I am sure!
For me, I am not gonna try to fix or improve on something that I am totally satisfied with--- and that is Ten Point!
12-07-2009, 06:11 PM
#10
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: MO.
Posts: 2,066
I shoot a Ten Point GT Curve and the HLX. One could not ask for better performance with either. I have not shot any Excaliber products, but based on testimoney from many users they seem to be first rate also.
As with many products today, if you have an opportunity to try both brands you will be better able to decide what works best for you! A decision between either of these brands will be a winner I am sure!
For me, I am not gonna try to fix or improve on something that I am totally satisfied with--- and that is Ten Point!
As with many products today, if you have an opportunity to try both brands you will be better able to decide what works best for you! A decision between either of these brands will be a winner I am sure!
For me, I am not gonna try to fix or improve on something that I am totally satisfied with--- and that is Ten Point!
whole heartly,I love my Ten Points!
