RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Snook-scamp grouper-sea bass any kind of bream in freshwater..

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

In my experience of the whole USA..:)

1st Brook Trout ...Pennsylvania mountain streams

2nd Walleyes ...Missouri

3rd Crappie/ Specks ...Buttermilk battered Florida

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

definately walleye and crappie

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Freshwater: Rainbow trout

Salt water: TUNA...fresh tuna steaks done on the grill is the best!!!

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Crappie are the best hands down...maybe 2nd place would be any type of catfish.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Cats, White bass, Stripe bass, Walleye, I agree with trout over a fire, Redfish, Salmon Fried or cooked over a grill.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

I like those little fish sticks from the freezer section of Walmarts.:D When I can't get those I settle for catfish and white perch. Actually, I like talapia in a pinch.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

For me,

1. Fresh tuna - cooking optional
2. Salmon - smoked, grilled or sashimi
3. Catfish - fried or grilled

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

I prefer yellow perch caught out of a deep cold northern lake. After this, my second preference is for walleye caught out of a deep cold northern lake. The preferred method of preparation is to lightly salt and pepper, dredge in flour, fry gently in bacon grease. This is how my late mother used to cook fish, and I have never tasted fresh water fish that was better prepared than this.

I also like salmon and swordfish, but I don't think I'm as pleased by them as by the perch/walleye fishes.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye, yellow perch, bluegill. Bluegill filets fried in a touch of butter, mmm-mmm-mmm!:D

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye no contest

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

sea-bass, hands down. caught one two weeks ago, deep fried it...mmm mmm mmm!!! thats what I call fresh!! it was swimmin only 30 minutes before it was in my mouth :). deep fried is the way to go, but almsot burnt my grandpa's house down in the process :D....


-Travis-

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye is excellent, perch is darn good too just takes a few more for a meal but my all out favorite is burbot. Don't worry they taste alot better than they look.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

What a tough question!!! When I was growing up in Illinois the staple was channel cat, bluegill, crappie and bass. Then moved to the mountains of Colorado and smoked snagged salmon, cutthroat, brookies for sure, and the deepest, reddest rainbow meat you've ever seen from Wyoming--yumm. Then moved to the west coast and hands down was sturgen and halibut and lingcod. If you ever see monkfish in your market buy some and cut it in small chunks, drop it in salted water and let it boil till it pops up to the top and dip it in butter....it's called poor man's lobster, and it is outstanding!!!!! tastes exactly like lobster!!! You can do that exact same thing to halibut too and it is unbelievably great!!!! A dinner of smallmouth is something I can never pass up either!!!!! For a real treat, smoke sturgen meat....it's amazing.......Then there is the walleye....one of the tastiest fish that swims.....how's that for a well rounded out answer to the fish eating question.....:)

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

For DINNER - Haddock - salt water - I cannot find a better tasting fish

Yellow Perch- freshwater - White cornmeal & flour - BEST snack going. - A dinner for all - is rare but wonderful if done right!

FH

[Deleted]
 

[Deleted by Admins]

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

trout

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

1. Bluegill or Yellow Perch at the local tap. The best there is!
2. Walleye, but only if I caught it through the iceand I prepare it myself. I hate mushy fish!
3. Northern Pike caught through the ice.
Bass and Crappie taste like mud when caught in the summer. Gotta get them through the ice!
Brian

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Well, since I am new to the forum and my first love is fishing, I must reply. Where I live (southeast Texas - between Houston and Beaumont) I have a lot of salt water and fresh water within 15-30 minutes, depending where I want to go. I fish about 2 times a week on average, and that includes deer season. For salt water, this is the order I like.

1st - Flounder
2nd - Speckle Trout
3rd-Whitting
4th - Red Fish
5th -Red Snapper
6th - Spanish and King Mackerels
7th - Maui maui
8th - many others

For fresh water, this is the order I like.

1st - Crappie (black or white)
2nd - Blue catfish
3rd - Channel catfish
4th - Various perch
5th - Rainbow trout
6th - Cut throat trout
7th - Brown trout
8th - Bass
9th - Walleye
10th- many more

Really as far as I am concerned, I eat pretty much any fish. I grew up fishing and fish so much that I supply our church with fish for two annual fish frys that feed about 300 people each time. I prepare the fish about 7 different ways from mild fried, spicy fried to blackened to grilled to a few others.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Freshwater = Walleye
Saltwater = Halibut, mahi mahi

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

I am not a big fish eater myself but nothing in my opinion beats a nice spicey Tuna Roll and various Sushi rolls.
If I was to throw sumptin on the grill Alaskan Salmon or Halibut.
But then again smoked trout is pretty good.
Hell I don't know there all pretty good and I dont have a favorite.;)

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye

If you get some Halibut... that is good eating as well!!

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Try taking walleye cut into cubes wrap in half a slice of bacon put a toothpick stick it threw to hold together,fry in a frying pan until the bacon is crisp this will also cook the walleye now take the bacon wrapped fish and spread it on a cookie pan spread your favorite BBQ sauce on and place in the oven on 350 until the BBQ sauce starts to carmelize.Takes some time but it is well worth it.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye or trout - it's a toss up for me

I make poor mans shimp out of my walleye - Cube up the walley fillet and then boil it in salt water - keep adding salt to the water till the fish cubes start to float -

Pearch and crappie are also good - Make up a batter with 7up instead of beer it makes the batter fluffier - dip the small fillets and then place in a deep fryer the kids all eat it up like candy

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Yellowfin Tuna and Wahoo tied.
Albacore and Pacific Yellowtail right behind.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

For me... Halibut! But, i've never caught one over 135 pounds either...

DM

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

smoked steelhead!!!!

or catfish deep fryed in peanut oil

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Sushi


Just kidding, although I do really like Sushi my favorite has to be Walleye.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Perch
Walleye
Whitefish (Especially smoked)

Only fish I really can't stand is salmon. Just never learned to like it.

GSG

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Oh, how could I of forgot ling......my mom makes a mean Ling chowder......catch'em through the ice when its pitch black, and you can hear the bells from your tip-upringing, and you're tripping over your pack, the dog, the fire [&:]Good times......[8D]

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Catfish and tartar sauce is the best fish meal ever.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

northern pike:) mmmm mmm good....

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Try putting down a piece of tin foil. Sprinkle on some season salt, followed by butter and some (few) onions and a few drops of Louisiana Hot Sauce, then a layer or two of Walleye fillets. Put the same mix on top of the filletsor in between if doing multiple layers. Rap edges TIGHT all the way around. Throw it on the heat and roll the package when it puffs like a balloon. Couple puffs and its done. More puffs if the package is thicker. Use heavy foil as you don't want it to blow out.

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Fresh water I love nothern pike 1st walleye 2nd
Salt water I just love grouper yum!
Store bought fish I like talapia or salmon

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Crappie by far, sauger next

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Walleye, steel head and chanel cat. In any order;)

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Does anyone else see what I see in this picture? Never seen it ate like that before!

RE: What fish do you feel is the best to eat?
 

Oh, and my favorite fish is channel cats, but wallye, perch and crappie are good too, as long as I caught them.:D