What is a trophy buck?
 

I was just wondering what everyone considered a trophy buck in their area. I believe any deer is a trophy, and wouldn't trade any I have shot for another. I just was wondering what kinds of bucks were in different areas? Here in Iowa we have a good supply of 120+ size deer, and they can make 200 although they aren't as plentiful.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

I've never payed much attention to size myself. And although I have yet to harvest a buck, I think of any animal I take as a trophy.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

A good buck in my aera is 125". Although we have some big deer in Maine we don't grow huge racks. Every year there are a couple of P & Y bucks taken but they are the exception, not the rule.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

A trophy is something special, not just any deer you shoot, thats an accomplishment. I consider bucks that are free roaming and make it to matureity trophys. A mature buck in my area will score 150 to 220, but who cares about score? Taking such a buck is a true acheivement, thus you get the trophy. For most people it is a once in a lifetime buck. Be proud of whatever you choose to shoot, but a fork horn is no trophy! its a 1st rack immature buck that has not learned enouph to keep from walking past your stand.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

In the Manitoba provincial big game record book, a whitetail must score 165 typical or 180 non-typical to qualify. There are well over 700 typical entries in the book and around 450 non-typical entries in the book. So there are some big deer out there, however if you are limiting it to bowhunting, any buck over 100 would be considered pretty decent by most hunters. The deer are tough to bowhunt and most bowhunters don't put in the scouting time to figure out how to get them in the large forested areas in the province. In my immediate area, our proximity to Riding Mountain National Park provides a large hunting free sanctuary for deer. Many large bucks only vacate the Park during the rut. So for this area there is a a fair difference in what is considered a trophy as far as a score goes. I think any deer taken with archery equipment is an excellent trophy.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

The biggest anybody I know has taken is 125", but an average big buck is about 110" around here. I saw one last year that was pushing 130" but blew the shot.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

Where my farm is, central WV, anything over a 6pt is a shooter. I would say a 110" buck is where trophy begins for me in that area.

Where I live, in Ohio, a trophy is over 140".

Personally, any deer I can take cleanly and quickly is a trophy. They all get me excited.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

in a fair chase situation every animal taken is a trophy in my eyes

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

I agree with bob d. They are all trophies. I have never seem a bad one yet. They all taste good too.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

What about the rank buck I shot when you were with me a couple of years ago, he definitely was made into JERKY!!![:@]

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

Oh yeh. All but one robinhood. That buck was so old I think that he was rotting on the hoof. I don't think that old boy had one more winter in him.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

I consider a trophy whitetail buck in Northern Idaho to score in the 140's gross or more ... our state record typical is 182 and change and our nontypical is 268 and change... a 130s with a bow is pretty hard to pass on. 120s let em grow! :)

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

a trophy is in the eye of the beholder

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

Most deer at the taxidermist in Ga. won't make 120. I'm not saying they are not trophy's. My first deer that broke 100 is on my wall. I'm just saying what I see. To shoot a deer around here that gets out of the 130's, YOU'VE DONE SOMETHING!
I've never seen a deer in the woods around here larger than 135. I see at least 1 bigger than that every year I go to the mid-west.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

Around here a trophy is a mature buck (5 1/2+) that scores 150"+.

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

:D I FEEL LIKE A TROPHY SITTING UP ON MY SUMMIT PLATFORM HOLDING MY BOW AS STILL AS ONE, 4 1/2 OR OLDER 140 AND UP I CAN TASTE HIM NOW

RE: What is a trophy buck?
 

I have to agree.