HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   Grimreapers??? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/393801-grimreapers.html)

miketodd58 08-18-2014 08:02 PM

Grimreapers???
 
For the peeps that are shooting Grimreaper mechanicals.

Which are you shooting and why?

razor tip or razor cut??

kellyguinn 08-19-2014 11:06 AM

I like them both. The only reason I decided to try the "Razor tip" was that the very tip of the razor cut would get dinged up sometimes after hitting the shoulder blade. Other than that I still use both and both get the job done.

I have switched over this year to try the killzone and the rages. The reaper replacement blades arent sold around me so I was having to purchase online. Good luck

miketodd58 08-19-2014 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by kellyguinn (Post 4154919)
I like them both. The only reason I decided to try the "Razor tip" was that the very tip of the razor cut would get dinged up sometimes after hitting the shoulder blade. Other than that I still use both and both get the job done.

I have switched over this year to try the killzone and the rages. The reaper replacement blades arent sold around me so I was having to purchase online. Good luck

That's what I was sort of leaning towards. That and I might get a chance to go hog hunting later in the season and I figure the tip might hold up better on hog.

cjclemens 08-21-2014 03:15 PM

If you're after hog, why not look into the Grim Reaper Fatal Steels? Solid stainless ferrule can't be a bad thing.

SecondChance 08-23-2014 05:56 AM


Originally Posted by miketodd58 (Post 4155005)
That's what I was sort of leaning towards. That and I might get a chance to go hog hunting later in the season and I figure the tip might hold up better on hog.

I have taken far more hogs and animals with my 100grn 1-3/8ths cut Razor Cuts and have NEVER had one fail to open or lost one due to mechanical failure. Lost 1 due to bad hit, too high.
I even took one of our a 300+lb WhiteTail here in Illinois and broke the vertabrae into 4 pieces and did not even break a blade!!! Drove it 8 inches through the disc. Hogs, blows through them. I also resharpen the blades myself. Leather glove and hold the blade against my thumb and sharpen with a EZ Sharpn tool. Good to go.

westMDbowhunter 08-23-2014 06:23 AM

Man you don't want grim reapers, go fixed blade for accuracy.
Let me tell a little story
I've been shooting 100 grain Muzzys from my bow since I first
Got it at sixteen. I'm 23 almost so that's seven years of shooting.
I can hit vitals ( about a ten inch circle)every time out to eighty yards with the Muzzys
Within 50 yards I typically can shoot the heart.
I couldn't tell you how many shots I've put through that old pse nova but it's a lot
My girlfriend got me a present, god bless her she thought she was doing a good thing.
Come to find out she had spent 50 bucks on three grim reaper broadheads, if I remember correctly one was a practice broadhead that did not expand?
She has no clue how us fixed blade guys are lol anyway I put them on my Arrows to make her happy
They were 100 grains so the drop from 20 to thirty should be the same as the 100 grain Muzzys.
In theory with the same weight broadhead you shouldn't have to adjust your pins just your entire sight.
So I moved my sight so that the grim reapers were hitting dead in bullseyes at 20 yards every time. Which they do very well. However try shooting much past that and you'll find out they definitely do not have "field point accuracy"
Groups out at forty yards were ridiculous, I'd say ten inch groups.
And fifty it was probably foot groups.
I have a 4x4 foot styrofoam block as a target and I wouldn't shoot the grim reapers out at sixty yards out of fear of losing my arrows.
I put back on my Muzzys and will never even glance at another mechanical.
All In all the things felt flimsy and poorly made, and they don't fly good at all
O rings are never going to be a part of my bow or my hunting
I have a few nice things to say, at 20 they flew very nicely so if your hunting a bait station and know your shot will be twenty or less you could use them (but you'd be just as happy with walmart cheapos at those yardages)
Ok one kind of alright thing to say about them....
Point is you aren't going to be shooting 5 inch groups at 80 yards like I do with muzzy

westMDbowhunter 08-23-2014 06:31 AM

Sorry for the lengthy story, bud their flight patters just suck
Probably perfect for hog hunting though right?
Like I mentioned if you were baiting then your shots would only be maybe 30 yards?
In that situation I'm sure they would do good.
But if you're deer hunting and might see a monster buck 80 yards to your left it would be nice to know you can make the shot. No way grim reapers groups would be good enough out at 80.

miketodd58 08-24-2014 09:27 AM


Originally Posted by westMDbowhunter (Post 4155612)
Sorry for the lengthy story, bud their flight patters just suck
Probably perfect for hog hunting though right?
Like I mentioned if you were baiting then your shots would only be maybe 30 yards?
In that situation I'm sure they would do good.
But if you're deer hunting and might see a monster buck 80 yards to your left it would be nice to know you can make the shot. No way grim reapers groups would be good enough out at 80.

I shoot maybe 60 yards in 3d circles but eastern hunts about 35 yards is a long shot.

SecondChance 08-24-2014 10:53 AM


Originally Posted by westMDbowhunter (Post 4155611)
Man you don't want grim reapers, go fixed blade for accuracy.
Let me tell a little story
I've been shooting 100 grain Muzzys from my bow since I first
Got it at sixteen. I'm 23 almost so that's seven years of shooting.
I can hit vitals ( about a ten inch circle)every time out to eighty yards with the Muzzys
Within 50 yards I typically can shoot the heart.
I couldn't tell you how many shots I've put through that old pse nova but it's a lot
My girlfriend got me a present, god bless her she thought she was doing a good thing.
Come to find out she had spent 50 bucks on three grim reaper broadheads, if I remember correctly one was a practice broadhead that did not expand?
She has no clue how us fixed blade guys are lol anyway I put them on my Arrows to make her happy
They were 100 grains so the drop from 20 to thirty should be the same as the 100 grain Muzzys.
In theory with the same weight broadhead you shouldn't have to adjust your pins just your entire sight.
So I moved my sight so that the grim reapers were hitting dead in bullseyes at 20 yards every time. Which they do very well. However try shooting much past that and you'll find out they definitely do not have "field point accuracy"
Groups out at forty yards were ridiculous, I'd say ten inch groups.
And fifty it was probably foot groups.
I have a 4x4 foot styrofoam block as a target and I wouldn't shoot the grim reapers out at sixty yards out of fear of losing my arrows.
I put back on my Muzzys and will never even glance at another mechanical.
All In all the things felt flimsy and poorly made, and they don't fly good at all
O rings are never going to be a part of my bow or my hunting
I have a few nice things to say, at 20 they flew very nicely so if your hunting a bait station and know your shot will be twenty or less you could use them (but you'd be just as happy with walmart cheapos at those yardages)
Ok one kind of alright thing to say about them....
Point is you aren't going to be shooting 5 inch groups at 80 yards like I do with muzzy

You said something about O rings. Did you have problems with the O rings on those reapers?
So far, out to 50yds, I shoot ethical distances with my weapons, I have yet to get any groups outside 8" with all 6 arrows.
Flimsy? So shooting through 55gal steel drums would not be a comparision for the durability of a broadhead? They shoot just fine through steel drums and stick in the opposite side with no damage to the ferrule or point. Just some of the blades need replacing or shaprening. And blowing through the gristle plates on a hog in and out. Wash off, resharpen and good to go!!! Brian Quacka AKA PigMan, can attest to this!!

SecondChance 08-24-2014 10:58 AM


Originally Posted by miketodd58 (Post 4155780)
I shoot maybe 60 yards in 3d circles but eastern hunts about 35 yards is a long shot.

Thank you. 80yds is beyond a ethical shot on a living critter no matter. You begin to get into the kenetic energy for sufficient pass through or even depth unless your shooting 100lbs draw and 650grn arrows to maintain the energy needed at that distance.
If you are supposedly able to keep those kind of groups at the said distances you stated, you are in the upper 1% of all archers known!!!

AR Bowhunter 08-24-2014 12:57 PM

Grim reapers don't have o-rings.

SecondChance 08-25-2014 05:12 PM


Originally Posted by AR Bowhunter (Post 4155809)
Grim reapers don't have o-rings.

Exactly my point!!! He stated that "O" rings will never be part of his rig set up. In the 2+ dz that I have bought and have been given by GR for several animals that I have sent them pics of, not 1 "O" ring yet!!! Well, that leaves GR's in the mix, no "O" rings!!! And $50 for a pack of 4, not 3 with one being a practice head. 3 Hunting, 1 practice.

miketodd58 08-25-2014 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by SecondChance (Post 4156035)
Exactly my point!!! He stated that "O" rings will never be part of his rig set up. In the 2+ dz that I have bought and have been given by GR for several animals that I have sent them pics of, not 1 "O" ring yet!!! Well, that leaves GR's in the mix, no "O" rings!!! And $50 for a pack of 4, not 3 with one being a practice head. 3 Hunting, 1 practice.

I paid $33.95 for a 3 pack of GR and it had a additional practice tip included. That was local. I've seen online prices about the same through Amazon and other retailers.

cjclemens 08-26-2014 08:16 PM

Yeah...not sure where ppl are getting this info. Reapers do not have O rings. $50 for a 3pack is mighty spendy, too. I never paid more than $35 for mine.

As far as hog hunting goes, my first choice would be the fatal steels as I mentioned before. Solid stainless ferrule and slightly smaller cutting diameter for better penetration. Second choice would be the 1 3/8 razor tip. Just the looks of the trocar style tip screams pass-thru.

And lastly, 80 yards is definitely too far of a shot. If your shot is that long, you screwed up when you set your stand. 80 yards for target practice? Heck yeah. When I'm hunting, it's 40 yards max. No exceptions.

And lastly, my BS alarm goes off as soon as I see someone mention muzzy's grouping at 80 yards...

foxfire66 08-27-2014 09:36 AM

I shoot both. I have been shooting the whitetail specials as of late. Awesome blood trail!

SecondChance 09-02-2014 12:46 PM


Originally Posted by cjclemens (Post 4156238)
Yeah...not sure where ppl are getting this info. Reapers do not have O rings. $50 for a 3pack is mighty spendy, too. I never paid more than $35 for mine.

As far as hog hunting goes, my first choice would be the fatal steels as I mentioned before. Solid stainless ferrule and slightly smaller cutting diameter for better penetration. Second choice would be the 1 3/8 razor tip. Just the looks of the trocar style tip screams pass-thru.

And lastly, 80 yards is definitely too far of a shot. If your shot is that long, you screwed up when you set your stand. 80 yards for target practice? Heck yeah. When I'm hunting, it's 40 yards max. No exceptions.

And lastly, my BS alarm goes off as soon as I see someone mention muzzy's grouping at 80 yards...


100% my point!!!! He said something about "O" rings in the beginning and I have shot them since they came out and have never had an "O" ring with them.
I buy my GR's here localaly at Bucheits and NAO Archery store for basically $35 a pack of 3 and don't use the proctice head. Trash can. I resharpen my practice heads and hunt with them on the same shaft they were tuned/practiced with.

hatchet jack 09-06-2014 05:59 PM

I just bought some 125gr Fatal steel GR.This is the first time I am going to try Mec heads. They do look well made and NASTY looking. Going to try and shoot one thru a Deer next Saturday. NJ Archery season opens Sept13th.

Hatchet Jack

Krypt Keeper 09-08-2014 12:22 PM

I have shot reapers for a handful of years, they are a great head

if the broadhead is sharp, flys good out of your bow, it will take a deer down. don't over think a broadhead, simple ones have worked for many years.

0-rings hahahahahaha
thats funny


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:22 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.