has anyone ever done this? im not a huge supporter of man made attractants like acorn rage or buck jam. has anyone ever tried walking through the woods with a bucket..filling it with fresh or old acorns...and then dumping a pile in your area? would this work to bring deer in? should you use whole acorns or smash them?

Lots of people do it...it sure does work...doesn't really matter about the form

You're going to laugh when I tell you this.........try pickiing up deer poop from an area far away from your hunting area and throw it around.


Deer very curious and will investigate the droppings of what they believe are new deer to the area.

When walking in, I always try to step in deer droppings or even cow pies if they are around. The more natural the smells, the better...

Very intersting

I MAY actually try this

Be careful moving even natural food around like that without checking out your local baiting laws. In Wisconsin, most of our state has a no baiting law and it covers moving acorns or apples or anything else to a new location, even if its on the same property. It is legal to hunt over these foods only if they haven't been moved in any way.

Moving acorns, hedge apples, etc to your area and putting them out is a good way to get movement thru your area. Even freshly cut corn that didnt make it into the combine is good too. Just check your land owner about that one because you are considered trespassing on his land to pick it up.

I did something like this several years ago with success. I scouted a couple of apple trees that were dropping and had a lot of deer coming to them so I set up over the trees. In 2 evenings I saw a lot of deer, but they were either out of range or the apples were in heavy cover offering no shots. So I went in early one afternoon and got myself as scent free as possible and using rubber gloves tossed some of the apples to a more advantageous position. Later that evening I was dragging a deer out.

Why not just hunt the spots where the natural feed is in the first place?Walking around in these areas leaving your scent will just put them off.Same goes for the area where you dump what you collected.You'll now have two places they wont want to go feed.Seems to me your just working against yourself.

+1,