Assume you have already used your only buck tag for the season, and out of nowhere comes a shooter buck walking your way. Right before he gets to within shooting distance both antlers fall off, would you shoot him knowing perfectly wellthat you can tag him as a antlerless deer or would you let him walk?

Walk's regardless If my buck tag Is filled or not.

Very interesting Schultzy! You have me curious, please elaborate!

Not even a decision. No shot.

What are the chances. I'd decide if the opportunity arose. Thinking about it right now, I'd shoot and go get the antlers and then mount him, if he was nice enough

Let him walk because I know where he may be next year.....

Even though I watched him shed his antlers, I like them on the head Instead of on the ground. I'd wait and hope like hell he'd show his face next year.

Let him walk and possibly get the 'second' set next year..lol

He would get a pass from me even if my tag was filled or not.

http://www.huntingnet.com/forum/tm.aspx?m=3304035