It has been alot of years since I last killed a buck, and never with a bow. I have left similar ones like him walk even last season and will again this year. I am getting a little tired of eating tag soup though, so my standards my drop alittle if I don't kill any this year. I think that next year I would have to say yes I would shot him.

depends on the time of year... close to the end of season and still no meat in the freezer then he would be getting stuck with the G5's.

If it was a clean, easy shot and towards the end of the season then yes.

Same as some of the others, if it's down to the last chance to get a deer, & no meat in the freezer; you bet I'd take him. I hunt more for the food than for the horns. We eat 2-3 ea yr.

With out a doubt yes

On public land, any archery buck is a good one...i'd smoke him, that's some good meat in the freezer!

Negative

Nope. To small for our land

25 to 30 years ago ,yes.

No.