Most of my friends & non-hunting family think I am Daniel Boone/Fred Bear reincarnated because all they know is I kill lotsa deer & some are big. And they have no clue.

To most hunters I know, I would guess they probably would think I am a little above average.

Myself, I know better in that I usually get the job done in a given situation, but I don't hold a candle to a lot of guys I consider great hunters.

And regarding being a good shot. I am a better hunter than I am a shooter. But both have come a long ways. The shooting probably more than the hunting.

im a great shot but there are others that are better and im a great hunter and yet again there are still others that are better than me

IM THE MAN!!

But seriously, among all of my hunting buddies, i generally shoot the most, and biggest, deer. Also, i generally win all of the summer shoots between the buddies. Im not expert though thats for sure, its all relative...

I'm much to arrogant to answer this Q.

But I am a far better hunter than a shootist.. I'm a good shot when I need to be.. but not a shooting expert for sure.

I won't vote.

I can relate to what a lot of you have already said.So much of this is relative.For my own goals and expectations I would consider myself good in both the shooting and hunting aspects,but this is coming from myself as an experienced hunter and someone who is very hard on themselves.
Within the local hunting community at large and within my family I believe I am seen as a very competent hunter.Like Ryan some of my gun hunting relatives can't fathom my success on nice bucks and bear with archery equipment.
I guess the most arrogant or confidant thing I would say is that I feel like I can hold my own with just about anyone and I think most would appreciate my enthusiasm for all aspects of hunting.

My parents are the same way they same i am a perfect shot, but i know i am notbut i am just starting to hunt alot so right now i would say a great shot but average hunter. Hopefully it will soon change to both being equal.

well with a bow, im not great, but i can shoot to kill a deer out to 30 yards. so i would say either a little below average, to average.
but, i know A LOT more about whitetails, and turkeys, than a lot of the people i have hunted with. i credit all of that to my dad. hes taught me everything i know.

There was not a choice for me but I would have to say average for both!

I think I am a better hunter than shot,with that said I can't remember the last deer I missed,but shooting at a dot is harder for me than shooyimg at a live animal.

I should be a better shooter. I don't practice enough. I do alright as a hunter. I put in a lot of time so eventually a buck is bound to wander by me.