3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
04-17-2008, 09:57 AM
#1
Dominant Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
I had a nice looking half-rack 2.5yr old in the woods I hunt in '06. I never got a photo of him.....but I often wonder if he's the 3.5yr old I got last year with a "funky" side....that ended up recovering nicely by the time the season rolled around. I had this deer at about 5 yds for 20 minutes, one morning (as a 2.5 yr old).
I wonder what my thought process would have been if he'd been older. I'll come clean....I only know (as well as one can) he was a 2.5yr old by things I've learned, since then (thoughI would have still guessed him at 2.5 then...based solely on rack). I ask myself, now.....what would I do if he was before me as a 3.5yr old with that same 1/2 rack?
Today.....I'd attempt to take him. With the number of sightings I get on deer that age.......I'd (IMO) be a fool not to.
Does the rack have "anything" to do with your thought process.....when you are confronted with a similar situation? We could come up with all kinds of scenarios.....but the question is simple....
Would any 3.5yr old get your arrow?
I wonder what my thought process would have been if he'd been older. I'll come clean....I only know (as well as one can) he was a 2.5yr old by things I've learned, since then (thoughI would have still guessed him at 2.5 then...based solely on rack). I ask myself, now.....what would I do if he was before me as a 3.5yr old with that same 1/2 rack?
Today.....I'd attempt to take him. With the number of sightings I get on deer that age.......I'd (IMO) be a fool not to.
Does the rack have "anything" to do with your thought process.....when you are confronted with a similar situation? We could come up with all kinds of scenarios.....but the question is simple....
Would any 3.5yr old get your arrow?
04-17-2008, 10:13 AM
#5
Dominant Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
Fair enough Rybo. I've come to the conclusion, though.......that ANY 3.5yr old is worthy of my arrow.....based SOLELY on the fact that he's 3.5. I know it's a personal decision we all make.....and I respect everyone's.
At the end of the season, though.......if I could say (not that I could actually DO it year in and year out) I took a 3.5yr old buck out of my woods........"I" would be tickled.
At the end of the season, though.......if I could say (not that I could actually DO it year in and year out) I took a 3.5yr old buck out of my woods........"I" would be tickled.
04-17-2008, 10:17 AM
#6
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Heaven is my home, temporarily residing in WNY :)
Posts: 6,679
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
I had a nice looking half-rack 2.5yr old in the woods I hunt in '06. I never got a photo of him.....but I often wonder if he's the 3.5yr old I got last year with a "funky" side....that ended up recovering nicely by the time the season rolled around. I had this deer at about 5 yds for 20 minutes, one morning (as a 2.5 yr old).
I wonder what my thought process would have been if he'd been older. I'll come clean....I only know (as well as one can) he was a 2.5yr old by things I've learned, since then (thoughI would have still guessed him at 2.5 then...based solely on rack). I ask myself, now.....what would I do if he was before me as a 3.5yr old with that same 1/2 rack?
Today.....I'd attempt to take him. With the number of sightings I get on deer that age.......I'd (IMO) be a fool not to.
Does the rack have "anything" to do with your thought process.....when you are confronted with a similar situation? We could come up with all kinds of scenarios.....but the question is simple....
Would any 3.5yr old get your arrow?
I had a nice looking half-rack 2.5yr old in the woods I hunt in '06. I never got a photo of him.....but I often wonder if he's the 3.5yr old I got last year with a "funky" side....that ended up recovering nicely by the time the season rolled around. I had this deer at about 5 yds for 20 minutes, one morning (as a 2.5 yr old).
I wonder what my thought process would have been if he'd been older. I'll come clean....I only know (as well as one can) he was a 2.5yr old by things I've learned, since then (thoughI would have still guessed him at 2.5 then...based solely on rack). I ask myself, now.....what would I do if he was before me as a 3.5yr old with that same 1/2 rack?
Today.....I'd attempt to take him. With the number of sightings I get on deer that age.......I'd (IMO) be a fool not to.
Does the rack have "anything" to do with your thought process.....when you are confronted with a similar situation? We could come up with all kinds of scenarios.....but the question is simple....
Would any 3.5yr old get your arrow?
not sure it's that easy to tell a 3 from a 2 all the time IMO...... especially since you were judging soley by the rack ............
but to answer your question .....probably getting shot ....assuming my freezer is empty and I'm not waiting for his daddy....
04-17-2008, 10:21 AM
#7
Dominant Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
not sure it's that easy to tell a 3 from a 2 all the time IMO...... especially since you were judging soley by the rack ............
I don't have any doubts the buck in the photos is 3.5. Could he be that deer I saw in '06? Maybe. But the point I was making is......even with the "funky" early rack.....I'd take this deer, now......if presented an opportunity.
04-17-2008, 10:24 AM
#8
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Heaven is my home, temporarily residing in WNY :)
Posts: 6,679
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
That's why I stated I initially "aged" him (before I knew any different) that way. Today.....I think I'm a little better at it.....especially given the time of year this was ( November).
I don't have any doubts the buck in the photos is 3.5. Could he be that deer I saw in '06? Maybe. But the point I was making is......even with the "funky" early rack.....I'd take this deer, now......if presented an opportunity.
not sure it's that easy to tell a 3 from a 2 all the time IMO...... especially since you were judging soley by the rack ............
I don't have any doubts the buck in the photos is 3.5. Could he be that deer I saw in '06? Maybe. But the point I was making is......even with the "funky" early rack.....I'd take this deer, now......if presented an opportunity.
04-17-2008, 10:24 AM
#9
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 7,208
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
Jeff,
For the most part I feel that way too, but I didn't include EVERY 3.5, just because if I ran across an extremely rare/odd 6 or less point 3.5 yr old, it would be illegal to shoot. And with my expanded hunting areas & efforts, I feel that I should be able to get a chance at a normal sized 3.5 yr old buck.
For the most part I feel that way too, but I didn't include EVERY 3.5, just because if I ran across an extremely rare/odd 6 or less point 3.5 yr old, it would be illegal to shoot. And with my expanded hunting areas & efforts, I feel that I should be able to get a chance at a normal sized 3.5 yr old buck.
04-17-2008, 10:25 AM
#10
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Central Minnesota
Posts: 9,445
RE: 3.5yr old.....get your arrow?
Nope! Just as I stated in Buckeye's thread I won't shoot a 3.5 unless he's easily a P&Y buck. Most 3.5's in my area are in that 125" to 130" range. I know there's bigger 3.5's too but I don't see them or there never close enough.