HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   FAST?? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/240479-fast.html)

BigDaddy12t 04-02-2008 04:31 PM

FAST??
 
So what do you concider "fast" when it comes to your bows

Matt/TN 04-02-2008 04:33 PM

RE: FAST??
 
280+ is a fast bowhunting setup in my eyes.



For Germ.....250fps :D

TexasBowHunter 04-02-2008 04:33 PM

RE: FAST??
 
400g @ 300fps

Splitear_Leland 04-02-2008 04:34 PM

RE: FAST??
 
When they try to get to second base on the first shot.

Really, I think anything above 250 is plenty fast for a hunting bow, and could be less.

idahoelkinstructor 04-02-2008 04:40 PM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: oilpatchpride

400g @ 300fps
I second that, any bow that can shoot a 400 grain arrow at 300 + f/s is fast in my book.

WesternMdHardwoods 04-02-2008 04:44 PM

RE: FAST??
 
wheres quik?

Vabowman 04-02-2008 04:46 PM

RE: FAST??
 
anything over the 280's is very quick, but anything over 300 is cooking, that is with the right size arrow for hunting.

idahoelkinstructor 04-02-2008 05:02 PM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: Vabowman

anything over the 280's is very quick, but anything over 300 is cooking, that is with the right size arrow for hunting.
I don't know about that, becauseyou need to figure in arrow weight as well. Some archers shooting 300 grain arrowsor less think thatis plenty for elk and other big game.High Country is taken taken this approach, they are claiming super fast speeds over 350 f/s but yet the arrowsweigh less than 300 grains. Sure it might be fast but theydon'thave the kenitc energythat a heavier arrow has at slower speeds.Thats why I say a 400 grain arrow going 300 f/s is fast. For hunting I like a 450 to 500 grain arrow going around 270-280 f/s. With this along with a stong fixed blade broadhead, it will blow through a elk out to 50 yards all day long. My Drenalin 30" draw lenght, at 70-71 poundsshoots a 505 grain (total weight)Full Metal Jacket at 274 f/s. Thats fast enough for me while hunting. This same set up with a 400 grain arrow it spits it out at 301 f/s.

Paul L Mohr 04-02-2008 05:03 PM

RE: FAST??
 
Personally I consider anything over 250 to be fast. Then again I am small. For an everage person I would say maybe 270 plus with over 60 lbs of draw weight and modern carbon arrows.

I personally don't shoot that fast, but if had a bow capable of faster speeds I would up my arrow weight until I leveled out around 250 fps or so. My set up will actually shoot around 270 or so if I use a light enough arrow, but I like heavier arrows and my speeds are closer to the 200-220 fps mark.

Paul

Rob/PA Bowyer 04-02-2008 05:05 PM

RE: FAST??
 
I agree with those that say, anything over 280fps is fast.

It really is.

bigbulls 04-02-2008 06:36 PM

RE: FAST??
 
Because no two shooters or set ups are created equally in regards to draw weight, draw length, arrow weight, etc... I look at what a bow can actually get from a realIBO set up.

I consider 310 - 320 to be"fast".
If it can do an honest320+.... that is "smokin".
If it can do a real340+.... that is "on fire".

drockw 04-02-2008 09:10 PM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: idahoelkinstructor


ORIGINAL: Vabowman

anything over the 280's is very quick, but anything over 300 is cooking, that is with the right size arrow for hunting.
I don't know about that, becauseyou need to figure in arrow weight as well. Some archers shooting 300 grain arrowsor less think thatis plenty for elk and other big game.High Country is taken taken this approach, they are claiming super fast speeds over 350 f/s but yet the arrowsweigh less than 300 grains. Sure it might be fast but theydon'thave the kenitc energythat a heavier arrow has at slower speeds.Thats why I say a 400 grain arrow going 300 f/s is fast. For hunting I like a 450 to 500 grain arrow going around 270-280 f/s. With this along with a stong fixed blade broadhead, it will blow through a elk out to 50 yards all day long. My Drenalin 30" draw lenght, at 70-71 poundsshoots a 505 grain (total weight)Full Metal Jacket at 274 f/s. Thats fast enough for me while hunting. This same set up with a 400 grain arrow it spits it out at 301 f/s.
thats exactly what my general shoots. i shoot a 29.5" 70# general with a 500 gr. (total) fmj. shot 275 on the money. plenty fast for me. i drop em in at 50 and they slam in just fine. no problem at all.

popeandyoungchaser 04-02-2008 09:54 PM

RE: FAST??
 
A hunting set-up that is shooting at 280 is fast and one that is doing 290+ is really getin'er!!

907Alaska 04-02-2008 11:07 PM

RE: FAST??
 
280fps

Doegirl75 04-03-2008 02:07 AM

RE: FAST??
 
This is fast...for me:D. 26" draw @50lbs:


smitdog 04-03-2008 02:29 AM

RE: FAST??
 
My Marquis is shooting 269,270 right now. I could change some things to get it faster,but my old bow was at 236fps, so I feel I'm shooting a barn burner right now.:)

Edcyclopedia 04-03-2008 04:45 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Fast or deadly?
I shoot about 241fps and have got a handful of deer.
My buddy shot a 1982 Hoyt he bought used that shot 175fps, he has more deer than me!
Speed's not the only thing that kills, but, yes it could help!

DeerStalker80 04-03-2008 05:42 AM

RE: FAST??
 
doe girl dont feel bad abot your speed I am a 27year old guy with a 26" draw length I shoot a guardian 70lbs a goldtip 3555 and my bow shoots 281 with a 355 grain arrow I have 61flbs of ke more than enough for deer and elk in my book. shoots deer out to 50 yards no problem+

drockw 04-03-2008 07:35 PM

RE: FAST??
 
thats why when i bought the general i didnt even care how fast it was. its so damn quiet. im not even gonna put any string silencers or vibrablocks on it b/c its quiet enough as it is.

Rory/MO 04-03-2008 07:52 PM

RE: FAST??
 
i think that anything 270+ fps is PLENTY fast enough

RockinChair 04-03-2008 07:57 PM

RE: FAST??
 
I prefer KE over FPS;)

idahoelkinstructor 04-03-2008 09:48 PM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: RockinChair

I prefer KE over FPS;)
I agree, but a bit of speed is good too.

bigbulls 04-04-2008 06:28 AM

RE: FAST??
 
With out speed there is no KE. ;)

RockinChair 04-04-2008 06:28 AM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: idahoelkinstructor


ORIGINAL: RockinChair

I prefer KE over FPS;)
I agree, but a bit of speed is good too.
Nooooo question. Faster speed, flatter arrow trajectory, more room for error in misyardage.

quiksilver 04-04-2008 06:36 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Agreed. I'm getting almost 80# of KE on a 290 grain arrow. (350 fps in my hunting setup)

archer58 04-04-2008 06:42 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Because I have a shorter DL 28-28.5 , most of the bows I've owned were around 270fps at best w/ my hunting arrows.
I don't know why , and I can't explain it , but I've all of a sudden found "a need for speed". I don't know where it came from , but I got the speed bug.
With the Synergy I have, a hunting weight arrow(375gr) is doing over290fps. That's 70.53# of KE.
I have a GTO ordered that willshoot that arrow at 300+. That's smokin'.

I would say that 290 is fast....but I'll never catch quicksilver.

Germ 04-04-2008 07:01 AM

RE: FAST??
 
I consider 250 FPS fast

I keep all my hunting bows between 230-250 FPS. I get pretty close to 80 lbs KE. I also get a quieter bow, more accurate and better performance in the wind.

I cannot think of a negative for shooting aheaviest setup you can for a hunting bow, being most of thekills are within 20 yds;)

quiksilver 04-04-2008 07:05 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Honest question guys -Regarding speed versus KE

Which of these two do you think are more likely to happen:
[ol][*]You misjudge the yardage and hit high/low; or[*]You make a good hit inthe vitals and don't have enough KE to penetrate.[/ol]

Let's just presume that both guys are using 60-70# bows, and both arrows are packing more than 55# KE. (likely)


Personally, I think I'm more likely to screw up (on a whitetail)by misjudging the yardage on a longer shot - than I am to lose a deer b/c I made a good hit but my arrow didn't penetrate. That's why I play the speed game.

Now if I were hunting rhinoceros or polar bears - my opinion would change.

WVSPORTSMAN 04-04-2008 07:10 AM

RE: FAST??
 
I LIKE ANY BOW PUSHING AN 385GR ARROW OVER 300 FPS...MORE SPEED THE BETTER THOUGH....QUIK...I DO AGREE THAT SHOT PLACEMENT IS BETTER OVERALL THEN K.E....MY GIRL FREIND DROPPED A DOE LAST SEASON WITH A BOW DOING 210FPS....ARROW WENT COMPLETELY THROUGH THE DEER.

gplant 04-04-2008 07:34 AM

RE: FAST??
 
29in Draw 60 lbs
310gr 331 fps76 lbs KE
385gr 310 fps 82 lbs KE

Germ 04-04-2008 07:46 AM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

Honest question guys -Regarding speed versus KE

Which of these two do you think are more likely to happen:
[ol][*]You misjudge the yardage and hit high/low; or[*]You make a good hit inthe vitals and don't have enough KE to penetrate.[/ol]


Let's just presume that both guys are using 60-70# bows, and both arrows are packing more than 55# KE. (likely)


Personally, I think I'm more likely to screw up (on a whitetail)by misjudging the yardage on a longer shot - than I am to lose a deer b/c I made a good hit but my arrow didn't penetrate. That's why I play the speed game.

Now if I were hunting rhinoceros or polar bears - my opinion would change.
From all the I hit them and can not find them threads, I am going to say option 2. You're assuming everyone can shoot:D
It's a matter of inchessometimes on penatration;)

Average whitetail is shot at 17 yds, which is why I play the KE game. Fran when I go elk hunting, I may go lighter. Right now I am above 550 grains. For Elk I may fo 425-450 because of distance.

switchbackXT_shooter 04-04-2008 07:51 AM

RE: FAST??
 
lets not for get silence. the bow must be quiet while spitting arrows at those speeds if its not then its not worth a da**. thats why I bought a mathews switchback orriginally. it was supper quiet in the shop shooting lane and it still had some giddy up to it.
I get 250 out of the hunting set up. its plenty for me.

quiksilver 04-04-2008 07:53 AM

RE: FAST??
 
See Gary - I think most of the bad hits (nonrecoveries) aren't a factor of KE lacking. Just bad shooting - and occasionally misjudging the yardage.

Germ 04-04-2008 07:55 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Switch shooter that is the big one IMO and most over looked.

Quick put a 550+ grain arrow on the HCA and then one of your speed rockets. All I can say is in 24 years of bowhunting I have never had a deer "jump" my string. I bet I shoot a slower setup than most here.



quiksilver 04-04-2008 08:10 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Really not all that much difference, Gary. I put an STS on it - bowjax on both limbs - and bowjax on the cables - and she's pretty quiet. All you can hear is the string slapping the STS bumper.

I agree though - it's a personal preference. And I can see both sides of the fence. But honestly, I think the perceived "need" for insane KE is overstated by most on this board.

I'd take a better trajectory 10 times out of 10 - as long as I'm hunting whities.

idahoelkinstructor 04-04-2008 08:11 AM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

See Gary - I think most of the bad hits (nonrecoveries) aren't a factor of KE lacking. Just bad shooting - and occasionally misjudging the yardage.
Quick, I bet its a bit or all the above, bad shooting, lack of KE and a few of a out of tune bows. If the arrow can't fly strait because its not in tune then there is no way its going to be able the penatrate either. Personaly your set up is way light for my taste, but to each their own. I would be willing to bet though my 500 grain arrowgoing 275 f/s, could out penatrate your 290 grain arrow going 350 f/s. In a friendly type of competition of course.;)

quiksilver 04-04-2008 08:16 AM

RE: FAST??
 
IEI - your setupmay or may not out-penetrate my bow (you have me by 4# KE). But does it really matter? We're both probably way overbowed for whitetails anyway. So it's a zero-sum game. For what it's worth, You might be surprised by the results of our "friendly game." I know I was. I had NO intent on hunting with this setup when I started experimenting with it. But I had enough confidence in it to lug it out there and my first shot at a deer was at 37 yards.

Honestly, it doesn't take much to punch through a ribcage. Hell, I shot 2 pretty nice bucks this year - passed through both.

Just like KE can be a crutch for bad shooting - speed can be a crutch for misjudged yardage.

idahoelkinstructor 04-04-2008 08:26 AM

RE: FAST??
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

IEI - your setupmay or may not out-penetrate my bow. But does it really matter? We're both probably way overbowed for whitetails anyway. So it's a zero-sum game. You might be surprised by the results of our "friendly game." I know I was. I had NO intent on hunting with this setup when I started experimenting with it.

Honestly, it doesn't take much to punch through a ribcage. Hell, I shot 2 pretty nice bucks this year - passed through both.

Just like KE can be a crutch for bad shooting - speed can be a crutch for misjudged yardage.
I'll drink to that, (coke a cola of course).But it still would be fun to do a test, maybe we could figure out a way for a bunch of us to test our equipment to see howit penatrates.Then we could postthe results along with arrow type,weight and speed . That would beawealth of valuable info if all involved had the same medium/target to test the equipment on.

Germ 04-04-2008 08:58 AM

RE: FAST??
 
Fran wait to you crutch one in the shoulder and I have with my setups. He looks good on the wall;)

quiksilver 04-04-2008 09:18 AM

RE: FAST??
 
To be totally honest, Gary - I think I may have blew through shoulder blade on Buck #2 this year. He was quartering-toward a little, and I hit a little forward and high entry. I never skinned him to see, but if I didn't hit the shoulderblade, I was close.

Smashed something pretty hard, b/c I heard it hit hard and the arrow was barely sticking in the ground.

The first deer was clean rib punchthrough - and it was buried 4" deep in the mud, far side.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:20 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.