Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Which is the toughest to harvest? Which has the ultimate survival tool (sense of smell vs. sight)? Which is the most rewarding to take? What gets the blood pumping the most?

I got into an argument with my dad over these questions today..

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Mature buck... no doubt. Now it turkeys could smell... YIKES

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Exactly. No question - Mature buck

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

It depends on to many varibles.

Most of all hunting pressure, being more deer hunters, I would go with mature buck.

But if you hunt where Bloodcreek drives to work, then every bird will be educated as Dancalls to them driving down the road

>BAM<

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

old gobbler!

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

[&:]Really?

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Mature buck, fewer and farther between.

My blood races with both, gobblers are all too common, bucks are individually destinquishable.

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Depends were you at

were i am at mature buck

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

Depends on where you hunt.;)

If God called down and told me I had to kill a 3.5yr old or older deer.....or a mature tom.

I'd choose the buck.

RE: Mature Buck or old Gobbler?
 

It makes it more of a challenge when they are educated :DBAM!
To answer the question, Mature buck by a long shot.