Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
03-05-2008, 05:12 PM
#1
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Cogan Station, PA
Posts: 2,298
Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
As a follow up to the "Would you take this shot?" thread, I was reading through my PA Game News and in the field notes, a story was submitted by WCO Stephen A. Leiendecker titled "Quite a Show," and it read,
A hunter told me that during archery season he heard a ruckus near his stand and then spotted two bucks locked in mortal combat. The larger of the two was a 13-point, exhausted but still alive. The other, a 10 point, had expired.
Interesting that no mention was made on what the hunter did. Thought it was interesting since I had mentioned in that thread about hearing of a story about one buck dragging a dead one that it had locked antlers with. I wonder how long these two had been locked and what the outcome was...
A hunter told me that during archery season he heard a ruckus near his stand and then spotted two bucks locked in mortal combat. The larger of the two was a 13-point, exhausted but still alive. The other, a 10 point, had expired.
Interesting that no mention was made on what the hunter did. Thought it was interesting since I had mentioned in that thread about hearing of a story about one buck dragging a dead one that it had locked antlers with. I wonder how long these two had been locked and what the outcome was...
03-05-2008, 05:49 PM
#2
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: York,Pa
Posts: 2,645
RE: Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
This one is a little easier! Being one is already dead I would not hesitate to shoot the other one! Then after I shot it I would contact the G.C. and let them know what happened and hopefully they let you keep them both for the mount, but if I know our G.C. they would want the one you did not shoot that was dead!
03-05-2008, 05:59 PM
#3
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: Hughesville, PA USA
Posts: 18,322
RE: Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
ORIGINAL: M.Hensler/PA
As a follow up to the "Would you take this shot?" thread, I was reading through my PA Game News and in the field notes, a story was submitted by WCO Stephen A. Leiendecker titled "Quite a Show," and it read,
A hunter told me that during archery season he heard a ruckus near his stand and then spotted two bucks locked in mortal combat. The larger of the two was a 13-point, exhausted but still alive. The other, a 10 point, had expired.
Interesting that no mention was made on what the hunter did. Thought it was interesting since I had mentioned in that thread about hearing of a story about one buck dragging a dead one that it had locked antlers with. I wonder how long these two had been locked and what the outcome was...
As a follow up to the "Would you take this shot?" thread, I was reading through my PA Game News and in the field notes, a story was submitted by WCO Stephen A. Leiendecker titled "Quite a Show," and it read,
A hunter told me that during archery season he heard a ruckus near his stand and then spotted two bucks locked in mortal combat. The larger of the two was a 13-point, exhausted but still alive. The other, a 10 point, had expired.
Interesting that no mention was made on what the hunter did. Thought it was interesting since I had mentioned in that thread about hearing of a story about one buck dragging a dead one that it had locked antlers with. I wonder how long these two had been locked and what the outcome was...
03-05-2008, 06:08 PM
#5
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Cogan Station, PA
Posts: 2,298
RE: Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
ORIGINAL: xXxrory7xXx
ya id like to hear the rest of the story
ya id like to hear the rest of the story
In all seriousness I would probably take the shot as well. Rob, it's funny you should mention forfeiting the antlers. My brother hit a monster 10 point in the early 90s just before the opening day of rifle. I can't remember the WCO who responded and came to our house (after we recovered the deer), but my dad was very close with many of them being a HTE instructor, and he wouldn't let us even keep the deer rack or no rack. I thought it odd. Another instance, my dad dispatched a mortally wounded doe maybe 10 years ago (hit by a car by our driveway), called the game comission and they took that as well.
03-05-2008, 06:21 PM
#6
Spike
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location:
Posts: 23
RE: Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
hey mat get this one. my buddy and i were going from my house to his house one night and about a mile from his house a 11 pointer was hit by a car and still alive! the cops were there and said that they couldn't shoot it to put it out of its misery? my buddy asked if he ran home to get his shotgun could he do it, and would he be able to take it? the cops said yes but the game commision was called. so we went but when we got back about 10 min later the cops were leaving and there was no deer? they said someone else stopped shot it and took the deer. can anyone tell me why the cops couldn't shoot it?? he made it sound like some kind of law?
03-05-2008, 06:48 PM
#7
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Cogan Station, PA
Posts: 2,298
RE: Suppose it happens more than we think...would you take this shot?
ORIGINAL: poconobowhunter
hey mat get this one. my buddy and i were going from my house to his house one night and about a mile from his house a 11 pointer was hit by a car and still alive! the cops were there and said that they couldn't shoot it to put it out of its misery? my buddy asked if he ran home to get his shotgun could he do it, and would he be able to take it? the cops said yes but the game commision was called. so we went but when we got back about 10 min later the cops were leaving and there was no deer? they said someone else stopped shot it and took the deer. can anyone tell me why the cops couldn't shoot it?? he made it sound like some kind of law?
hey mat get this one. my buddy and i were going from my house to his house one night and about a mile from his house a 11 pointer was hit by a car and still alive! the cops were there and said that they couldn't shoot it to put it out of its misery? my buddy asked if he ran home to get his shotgun could he do it, and would he be able to take it? the cops said yes but the game commision was called. so we went but when we got back about 10 min later the cops were leaving and there was no deer? they said someone else stopped shot it and took the deer. can anyone tell me why the cops couldn't shoot it?? he made it sound like some kind of law?
