I think, if I had the choice, I would shoot the Hanson buck, I love the look of that rack. Non-typicals just don't have the same effect on me as a HUGE "typical"(if you can call the Hanson buck typical).

either one

As I have yet to see a non-typical, I'd have to say the St. Louis buck. That and the possiblity that maybe some of his genes are still in the pool where I can hunt.

Looks like I'm going to go with the majority on this one. The Hanson buck is a beautiful deer, and if I did have a chance to take him I would have to cut a hole in my ceiling to fit the rack on my wall.

You mean after I regained consciousness? I would take the first one that presented a shot. Period.

At first glance I would shoot the non typ. Look at all that bone! If I found out later I passed up the wr typ. I would be sick. Here is another good ethics question. Who would only shoot one if you had a chance to shoot both?

I would wait until they were lined up then shoot them both... since here in michigan I get two Buck tags!

Since we are assuming they are alive, I would shoot the non-typical. The Hanson buck was only 3.5 years old and I bet he could really add to that rack in the next year or so!

Now, if Iwake up from my dream and they are both still out there, I would put an arrow into the first one I had a chance to...and have another arrow ready for the next shot.

The first one that gave me a good clean shot.

I have to say this is one of the most amazing pictures I have ever seen, lol