HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/226696-hni-thinktank-arrow-coatings.html)

brucelanthier 01-11-2008 10:07 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
On a TV hunting show the other night I saw what I believe they called a "green hunt" (not sure though about the name). It was a bowhunter in Africa that was going to shoot a rhino in the back hindquarter with a dart tipped arrow. They (vet & management people)needed to sedate the rhino so that they could get blood to test and take measurements. Anyway, they mounted the dart on the arrow, the guy got within about 25 yds and shot him. It all worked out the way it was supposed too. I think the guy mentioned that SCI recognizes these "records" under this "green hunt" label (green hunt meaning not killing the animal). Thought it was interesting. Don't know if it adds to this topic or not though :D.

quiksilver 01-11-2008 10:15 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
Bruce: I got lambasted last year for suggesting that the same tactic should be legalized for hunting whitetails in the U.S. Granted, I didn't call it "green hunting" because I was unfamiliar with the term... I believe the thread was called "Catch and Release Hunting" and all the HNI "inside-the-box thinkers" were peeing themselves with anger and vitriol over the whole thing. No surprise really.

I mean, you see a nice,but still immature buck - you take him down with your sedative arrow, take a few field photos and measurements - have your taxi build you a set of replica antlers to puton the mount. Maybe shoot him again next year.

Isn't that the ultimate in "letting them go so they can grow?" I mean, if it's SUCH a great idea for fish, I don't know how it could possibly be that bad an idea, as applied to mammals.

Funny how I always get labeled as crazy - but then we see these things actually happening (past or present). Amazing how that works. [:-]

Cougar Mag 01-11-2008 10:21 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
I can catch and release with my camera........but thats just me.

GR8atta2d 01-11-2008 10:21 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

Nevermind Gr8 - you missed the whole point. I told you to ignore whether it was legal or not. You couldn't seem to get over that hurdle.
And thats a shame because, it was such a hurdle on an otherwise great thread..My mind could not grasp the scenerio to the depths of yours..You are such a deep and profound thinker, I profess to be as great as thou someday...

What level Klingon Commander have you reached??

Cougar Mag 01-11-2008 10:24 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
I wish you two would shake hands or kiss and make up.

MN/Kyle 01-11-2008 10:24 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

Bruce: I got lambasted last year for suggesting that the same tactic should be legalized for hunting whitetails in the U.S. Granted, I didn't call it "green hunting" because I was unfamiliar with the term... I believe the thread was called "Catch and Release Hunting" and all the HNI "inside-the-box thinkers" were peeing themselves with anger and vitriol over the whole thing. No surprise really.

I mean, you see a nice,but still immature buck - you take him down with your sedative arrow, take a few field photos and measurements - have your taxi build you a set of replica antlers to puton the mount. Maybe shoot him again next year.

Isn't that the ultimate in "letting them go so they can grow?" I mean, if it's SUCH a great idea for fish, I don't know how it could possibly be that bad an idea, as applied to mammals.

Funny how I always get labeled as crazy - but then we see these things actually happening (past or present). Amazing how that works. [:-]
Trail cams, or Digi cam's will work, and they normally don't risk killing the deer, or any other mammal. I wonder how many people would be mauled by animals waking up from thier "sleep". Too many things could go wrong with this IMO.

quiksilver 01-11-2008 10:28 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
Don't worry, Gr8. Not everyone can be this awesome. The world needs balance.

MN/Kyle: You just can't give that type of weapon to the blundering redneckhordes. It's a recipe for disaster. Like giving matches and gasoline to an arsonist.

brucelanthier 01-11-2008 10:36 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

Bruce: I got lambasted last year for suggesting that the same tactic should be legalized for hunting whitetails in the U.S. Granted, I didn't call it "green hunting" because I was unfamiliar with the term... I believe the thread was called "Catch and Release Hunting" and all the HNI "inside-the-box thinkers" were peeing themselves with anger and vitriol over the whole thing. No surprise really.

I mean, you see a nice,but still immature buck - you take him down with your sedative arrow, take a few field photos and measurements - have your taxi build you a set of replica antlers to puton the mount. Maybe shoot him again next year.

Isn't that the ultimate in "letting them go so they can grow?" I mean, if it's SUCH a great idea for fish, I don't know how it could possibly be that bad an idea, as applied to mammals.

Funny how I always get labeled as crazy - but then we see these things actually happening (past or present). Amazing how that works. [:-]
The difference here, I think, is that they needed to sedate this rhino for "legitimate" (for want of a better word) reasons and weren't doing just so the guy could get it on the ground. I have looked on the SCI website for any reference to this green hunt business but have not found it yet. At this point I am assuming, maybe wrongly, that there is some need to sedate the animal in the green hunt scenario which would make it quite a bit different than the catch and release deal.

MN/Kyle 01-11-2008 10:39 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 

ORIGINAL: quiksilver

Don't worry, Gr8. Not everyone can be this awesome. The world needs balance.

MN/Kyle: You just can't give that type of weapon to the blundering redneckhordes. It's a recipe for disaster. Like giving matches and gasoline to an arsonist.
Where would you start?

Charlie P 01-11-2008 10:41 AM

RE: HNI Thinktank: Arrow Coatings
 
I talked with the inventor of the pod at length many times about this subject he died a few years ago.

The stuff he used would not kill a human supposedly

I think it would be a pandora's box.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:44 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.