so many would take the non... what if the non-typical suddenly became "typical"??? kinda like when alternative music becomes mainstream is it really alternative anymore???

The first 1 to give me the shot , If both were 10 yards from me broadside , the nontypical is going down .

IMO both are very nice bucks. I would have to take which ever gave me the first clean shot! But the non-typ. is very nice, alot of character.

I'd shoot the non-typical without hesitation... and it seems that 80% agree.

The non typical has so much more mass and everything. Without a doubt.

easy decison, the non typ has a once in a life time rack.

I would have to agree with everyone else here , that nontypical sure is a nice one and I would shoot that one over the eleven pointer but if that eleven pointer came by and offered a nice broadside shot I wouldn't pass it up either.

How bout you take me hunting with you and I'll shoot which ever one you don't. And then you cantake pics with both !!!

On a serious note...you obviously have access to a great piece of land. I would take the non, and monitor the property and cross your fingers n toes and maybe that 11 is huge next year. He looks younger then the non. And you get both......or again you can take me and both can go down.

Niether in front of that feeder, but elsewhere Typical

Saved me some typing Soap, my thoughts exactly.