RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

I agree. If he's sagging now he's really gonna pack on the pounds when the acorns drop!

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

he is perfectly symmetrical so he would make p&y, i'd say no older than 4.5, but if I was bettin' i'd say 3.5, nice deer though!

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

However old he is he's a good looking buck. Good luck finding him this fall.

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

He's 3.5 and he will be short of p&y, he is a nice buck... Depending your area you are in I am pretty sure he's 3.5 I dont think he's anyolder...Good buck, smoke him if ya want him...

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

I would have to say 3.5 year olds and I think he will miss P&Y by a few inches, he should gross around 125" but after deductions he wouldn't net P&Y! Either way he is a beautiful buck and would look great on the wall!

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

Thanks for all the input fellas...I'd have to agree that he's at least 3.5 years old. I buddy of mine thinks he's young...but that body doesn't lie. He runs with another big bodied 8 pointer with a lot of mass and super long brow tines...but not great tine length and no spread. (I'll post a pic of him sometime too).

Here's another picture of the same buck looking straight on. At first I thought he might squeak into P&Y...but I think Buck Magnet is right.

Good luck to you guys as well.

RE: Good Buck (pic)
 

The main thing that is hurting him is his main beams. If he had about 4" more sweep in at the end of his beams he would definetly net P&Y. His G-1" appear to be about 4", G-2's about 8", and his G-3's should be in the 6.5" range. He is still a beauty of a buck and I don't think that I could hold out if he was standing at 20 yards broadside!

RE: Good Buck (2nd pic posted)
 

I think you're right Magnet.....and I definitely won't pass on this guy if I getthe opportunity. He'd look too good in the back of my truck and on the wall too.

RE: Good Buck (2nd pic posted)
 

Definetly would make a beautiful trophy, good luck on him buddy, can't wait to see the pics of him layin beside you!

RE: Good Buck (2nd pic posted)
 

I agree with 3 1/2yrs old. I think he's just shy of P&Y though. Still a shooter in my area.;)