2 pics on from last year the other from this year. Now this is why I am posting this do you think they are the same buck at first I diden't think so but now thinking maybe thay are. What do you think? The second one is from a post I put up last week named "how old and would you take it " something like that just in case you were woundering .

honestly i dont think there is any way of telling. there is nothing unique about the second deers rack thaat gives it away as the same deer for example a non typical. just my 2 cents.

I beleive that they are the same deer if you look at the tine farthest back towards his head he still has that same curved in look, at least thats my opinion.

no not the same deer

I don't believe they are, but who really knows?

No way of telling at this age really. I doubt they're the same deer simply based on the main beam difference. Yes the first horn has a similar hook, but the angle is funny and who knows. But the main beam on the second deer is no where near like the first picture. But again, who knows.

I dont know but i think they are different.

I think your looking at two different deer there.

yea i dont think they are the same deer. but who's knows thats just my 2 cents