goherd1111

Okay guys. I know how much everyone likes the "Score this Buck Thread" so I'm gonna do it to you again. I need help. I have one more IL buck tag to fill but I want to kill a deer larger than the 12 point I already killed. I'm gonna show you pics of the one I killed and then show you a trail cam pic that I got today about 20 yards from my treestand. Let me know what you guys think this nice 8 point would score. My 12 point scored 132". I just want to here some of your guys' opinions. I know I have to make the ultimate decision whether or not to trip the release if given the opportunity. So that being said. Let me know what you guys think.What do you think he would score and would you take him if you were in my shoes.
Here are two pics of the buck I have taken this year.



Now here is a pic of the deer I am considering taking if given the opportunity.

Matt/TN

low 140's, the little browtines kill him, maybe high 130's. Although this is just my opinion

Brocster

Low 130's. He looks like a deer I shot a few years ago.

Schobs

I dont have a guess at the score, ive never been good at that, but i'll ask u this, would u rather wait all season for a buck bigger than your 12, and possibly not fill your tag, or get this guy the next time you go out and have your season end on a nice note? hope this helps, good luck in your decision, real nice 12 pointer by the way, lots of character.

duckhunter669

Long beams is all he has going for him,let him walk till naxt year.

kwaldeier

130 3/4

goherd1111

I don't want to kill another buck off of this property this yearunless he is considerably bigger than my 12 point.

goherd1111

Will this deer get much bigger next year. I think he is a 3.5 year old deer.

njbuck22

I would say maybe gross score in the low 140s. I would send an arrow at him. The 12 point has some great character.