RE: Shooter or Not?
 

An eight point buck with a spread like that , yea I would shoot it .
I would say he's about tow years of age and he might score around 115 to 120.
Nice buck good luck on shooting him this fall.

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

Yes.... but if i was hunting my land i would wait two years first.

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

Yes, id shoot him, i dont see alot of bucks in my area, especially during the early season. So i would take him. Nice Buck

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

definite yes anything around here with antler(s) is a shooter

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

Yup....I would.

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

Me personally no i would not shoot, but for you if it is your biggest buck yet to date then most diffentently or if it just makes you happy then that is what its all about. If he was on my land give him two more years.. Walt

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

On the public land where I hunt...you'd better shoot him or someone else would. However, if I had my own land...like others have said...I'd let him grow.
Good luck.
Craig

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

Navydeerhunter
someone didn't shoot him last year so that theory doesn't hold water.

I agree to the size (100-105) and age 2 1/2 and for me he is not a shooter. But if he makes you happy go for it.

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

That deer is a 2 1/2 and he scores closer to 120 than he does 100. If you like him, take him. If you're not sure, pass him. Pretty good approach.

RE: Shooter or Not?
 

That's a shooter where I come from.

Chris