Should we shoot him or give him another year?

Knowing where you are located and seeing some of the bucks you've posted, I think you should let him walk another year. Just my $.02

Can't answer that for your neck of the woods...but for me, in N.C.he would be DOWN!!

I will need to know the exact location (with maps please) in order to provide a definitive answer.

heck i would shoot that in a quick minute i hunt for the meat i kill whatever walks in front of me as long as it looks a good size but i hunt public land so if its there i shoot if it looks like 150 lbs or more

Nice pics

What type of food plot is that?

Id shoot him if I had a chance...

I would let him grow one more year, if nobody else has there eyes on him.

1 more year....

let um walk