Hunting buddy says yes, I say no. What do you think?

I would definetly shoot it, and then get it mounted.

It was a shooter last year.

I am with your buddy. Shoot that dude!!

I wouldn't think twice about shooting him. He's one fine looking deer.good luck getting him.

in a heart beat

Ridiculous question. It's all relative to where you hunt.

To some -yes. To others-no. To me-YES! He's ready for SMACK DOWN 2006 FOR SURE!!

If you don't think it is a shooter then don't shoot it. You are the one that makes the choice. What ever your choice it is the right choice because it is yours.

yep ., it is up to you ., now where i hunt i dont have the land where i can pass him up ., so i would shoot him .,but if you have the land and you can pass him up for a chance at him next year then do it ., but if you are like me ., and you dont have the land ,.he might not be there next year! just my thoughts!! good luck what ever you do.,