Big Buck Found
12-09-2005, 09:53 PM
#14
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: New Jersey USA
Posts: 1,279
RE: Big Buck Found
Awesome buck! Good luck for you friend! I think P&Y would have to accept it, but I don't see why he would enter it knowing it came from a pen. Atlas, man you need relax. The guy didn't do anything wrong, and you have no idea what the circumstances regardingthis deers life was...
12-09-2005, 10:09 PM
#15
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Damascus MD
Posts: 2,751
RE: Big Buck Found
Ahh give Atlasman a break, he's a vegetarian obviously if he thinks this story is sad. Of course Atlasman wouldnt have shot the deer, he would have been able to tellit was raised in a cage its whole life and defensless to boot. I think the sadest part is Atlasman's inability to comprehend things that dont happen to him.
No, the buck probablyshouldnt be allowed in the books IMO. And hell yeah, its a beautiful buck. I dont see what the hell is sad about this story, seems like a happy ending to me. Plus we get to see Atlasman quote the heck out of everyone, woohoo!!!
No, the buck probablyshouldnt be allowed in the books IMO. And hell yeah, its a beautiful buck. I dont see what the hell is sad about this story, seems like a happy ending to me. Plus we get to see Atlasman quote the heck out of everyone, woohoo!!!
12-09-2005, 10:11 PM
#16
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Michigan/Ohio
Posts: 11,682
RE: Big Buck Found
I think he killed a defenseless pen raised deer. Can't imagine being too excited over killing a helpless pet that has had it's instincts dulled by living in a cage.
Sad story.
Sad story.
12-09-2005, 11:13 PM
#17
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Cushing, OK
Posts: 107
RE: Big Buck Found
What a hoss! Your buddy took the deer fair and square. No regrets, and he should go in the books. This is the result of an act of God, and a once in a lifetime event. I'm sure that there are several in P&Y and B&C that fall into the "dumb luck" category. From reading your account, I assumed that a rifle was used, but that would put him in B&C. He saw the deer at 100 yds and then shot after seeing the rack. That rules the bow out. On the other hand, if a bow was used, then how could he miss seeing the tag? I guess that's what it all hinges on for me. Either way, nice wallhanger.
12-09-2005, 11:16 PM
#18
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Cajun Country
Posts: 93
RE: Big Buck Found
ORIGINAL: Okie807
What a hoss! Your buddy took the deer fair and square. No regrets, and he should go in the books. This is the result of an act of God, and a once in a lifetime event. I'm sure that there are several in P&Y and B&C that fall into the "dumb luck" category. From reading your account, I assumed that a rifle was used, but that would put him in B&C. He saw the deer at 100 yds and then shot after seeing the rack. That rules the bow out. On the other hand, if a bow was used, then how could he miss seeing the tag? I guess that's what it all hinges on for me. Either way, nice wallhanger.
What a hoss! Your buddy took the deer fair and square. No regrets, and he should go in the books. This is the result of an act of God, and a once in a lifetime event. I'm sure that there are several in P&Y and B&C that fall into the "dumb luck" category. From reading your account, I assumed that a rifle was used, but that would put him in B&C. He saw the deer at 100 yds and then shot after seeing the rack. That rules the bow out. On the other hand, if a bow was used, then how could he miss seeing the tag? I guess that's what it all hinges on for me. Either way, nice wallhanger.
He used a rifle.
B&C is what I should have written.
12-10-2005, 12:08 AM
#20
Fork Horn
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: N.W. Wisconsin
Posts: 308
RE: Big Buck Found
Nice buck. COngrats to the hunter.
THe buck was in the free-range wild woods, when he was harvested, so I see no problem with it.
BUt I don't think it should be accepted into the record books, since it was a pen raised deer for the majority of its life.
I too think it should be mounted with the tag in its ear, and the hunter should get some info from the game farm about this buck if he can.
THe buck was in the free-range wild woods, when he was harvested, so I see no problem with it.
BUt I don't think it should be accepted into the record books, since it was a pen raised deer for the majority of its life.
I too think it should be mounted with the tag in its ear, and the hunter should get some info from the game farm about this buck if he can.