here's a debate for ya.
 

Which deer do you take in IL-Cornfed's Avatar???? if that's what it's called.

http://forum.hunting.net/asppg/upfiles/26330/079F4A83FD7E4EB98DA5AE69CD444537.jpg

I think I'd go non-typical myself!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd take that big typical..... Could you imagine that thing slipping through the woods on a cold November afternoon? :D

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

If I saw either of those deer from my stand and they were within shooting range, I'd probably just sit there and enjoy the yellow tear running down my leg because I don't think I'd remember how to work my bow!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd probably go for the typical as well. ;)

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'll never see anything like either one of those deer where I hunt in NC but I'd take the typical if I had to choose. But let it be known that I'd GLADLY take either one:D

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would wait until they were both broadside with one standing behind the other and take both at the same time!

I would be very happy to take either one as I dont' think I will ever see anything that big but if I had to make a choice, it would be the non-typical. I just think he has more character.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd take the non-typical. Just because I like those non-typicals. Looks like a tree walking through the woods.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would also go for the typical.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

It would be the one that gives me the best shot[&:]

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Whichever came in range first ;)

Either way, you'll have a world record.