here's a debate for ya.
 

Which deer do you take in IL-Cornfed's Avatar???? if that's what it's called.

http://forum.hunting.net/asppg/upfiles/26330/079F4A83FD7E4EB98DA5AE69CD444537.jpg

I think I'd go non-typical myself!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd take that big typical..... Could you imagine that thing slipping through the woods on a cold November afternoon? :D

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

If I saw either of those deer from my stand and they were within shooting range, I'd probably just sit there and enjoy the yellow tear running down my leg because I don't think I'd remember how to work my bow!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd probably go for the typical as well. ;)

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'll never see anything like either one of those deer where I hunt in NC but I'd take the typical if I had to choose. But let it be known that I'd GLADLY take either one:D

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would wait until they were both broadside with one standing behind the other and take both at the same time!

I would be very happy to take either one as I dont' think I will ever see anything that big but if I had to make a choice, it would be the non-typical. I just think he has more character.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'd take the non-typical. Just because I like those non-typicals. Looks like a tree walking through the woods.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would also go for the typical.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

It would be the one that gives me the best shot[&:]

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Whichever came in range first ;)

Either way, you'll have a world record.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

go for the typical because there is nothing like seeing a tall tined perfectly symmetrical rack

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Definately the Non, then I would go back that afternoon and get the typical;)

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I will take the 3rd one that is bedded down behind them.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Typical all the wayif I had a choice. What a choice to have!!!!!!!!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

If they were still within range after I changed my drawers, stopped shaking and popped my eyes back in. I'd take either one. I like the Non-Typical. Big time character. Pretty much sums up what my reaction would be.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

yeah i have to agree. i'm not sure which one i would choose though. i guess when the situation arises i'll let ya'll know ;)

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would go for the typical!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I'm with you!

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

i would take the non typical because of the funky rack

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Non typical...they are freakish looking....I like that
Typical....symetrical, neat........I like that

Oohh Daddy...can I have em both??

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

1. that non-typical
2. stand just like that and put them both down with one shot...a two-fer...just kidding the non-typ

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

I would be happy with either one.I guess I would have to take the non typical first day and the typical the second day out.I have plenty of typicals on my wall I need a huge non typical to complete my collection.Truth be known I would take which ever one presented me with the sot first.

RE: here's a debate for ya.
 

Neither one.... this looks like a doctored picture of two deer that are already dead. The one on the right looks like Milos deer and the other... that Ohio kid is it??? I don't know, but I think these are dead deer.[:'(]