RE: Rattlin Bags?
 

I havent tried rattling bags yet, but

RE: Rattlin Bags?
 

I havent tried a rattling bag but I did pick up a power rattle from Mad calls. Its a lot
louder then real antlers, should work good when its windy out or when you want to be aggressive.

RE: Rattlin Bags?
 

i have a rattle bag i believe its a knight & hale and it works just fine its rattled in a few deer and it sure is alot easier to tote through the woods then a set of real antlers

RE: Rattlin Bags?
 

I have used both and don't really see much difference. When the bucks are rut wild, it really doesn't matter. My grandfather occasionally found rocks that he would pop together and roll around in his had to bring them in. I think its more in cadence then anything. I was a firm believer in real horns but since using a bag and rattling in some pretty nice bucks, I'll stick with it. Lot easier to carry too.