Just found out Deer season is still in, in Indiana
#12
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 360
Boy I sure don't understand that philosophy??? This action would not work well in any deer management program I know. You would better off killing more does then bucks is you want to maintain a good trophy population.
I admit I am no expert, but have researched this for my hunt club. We have over 4000 acres and try to manage our deer pop as much as possible.
I admit I am no expert, but have researched this for my hunt club. We have over 4000 acres and try to manage our deer pop as much as possible.
We have 7 kids between me and my two friends that I hunt with. Believe me there are plenty of doe killed. This year was just a funny year, things didn't seem to flow the way they usually do. Last year by the second weekend of December, I alone had taken two buck and 7 doe. And I took my bucks before I started taking doe. So, I am not sure what you are assuming, with your post.
Do you think shooting a bunch of doe first is going to give you a better chance at a quality buck, later in the season?
#13
We have 7 kids between me and my two friends that I hunt with. Believe me there are plenty of doe killed. This year was just a funny year, things didn't seem to flow the way they usually do. Last year by the second weekend of December, I alone had taken two buck and 7 doe. And I took my bucks before I started taking doe. So, I am not sure what you are assuming, with your post.
Do you think shooting a bunch of doe first is going to give you a better chance at a quality buck, later in the season?
(BP)
#16
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Tennessee
Posts: 1,607
I wont kill doe untill my buck tags are filled and I will take anything 4.5 or older, no matter the score. In my area that seems to be 140" or better. If you would limit yourself to these size deer, you may have more B&C or P&Y bucks in your area Just Razzin Ya, Back!!
That's not the case where I hunt. Heck a 7yr old buck might still only be a 130. We don't have the genes or ground to grow them like the midwest. Though I was reading an article not too long ago discussing the many different subspecies of whitetails in the US. That could have more to do with it than people realize.
#17
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: River Ridge, LA (Suburb of New Orleans)
Posts: 10,917
That's not the case where I hunt. Heck a 7yr old buck might still only be a 130. We don't have the genes or ground to grow them like the midwest. Though I was reading an article not too long ago discussing the many different subspecies of whitetails in the US. That could have more to do with it than people realize.
#18
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 360
That's nice that you have some extended time in the woods.
That's not the case where I hunt. Heck a 7yr old buck might still only be a 130. We don't have the genes or ground to grow them like the midwest. Though I was reading an article not too long ago discussing the many different subspecies of whitetails in the US. That could have more to do with it than people realize.
That's not the case where I hunt. Heck a 7yr old buck might still only be a 130. We don't have the genes or ground to grow them like the midwest. Though I was reading an article not too long ago discussing the many different subspecies of whitetails in the US. That could have more to do with it than people realize.
When they began restocking Indiana with whitetail in the 1930's they brought about 400 deer which were trapped and transferred from Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania and North Carolina. They were pretty well exstinct here before that time frame and untill the late 70's it was unusual to see a deer in the wild.
Now we have a healthy herd and record hunting numbers every year. Somewhere around 125,000 taken in season.
When me and my buddies see a small buck, we always joke about how that one must have came from PA or NC
#19
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 360
#20