HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Black Powder (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/black-powder-23/)
-   -   New APP - Super Powder (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/black-powder/342190-new-app-super-powder.html)

Muley Hunter 03-20-2011 08:31 AM


Originally Posted by MountainDevil54 (Post 3788764)
If T7 works so good for you guys, whats with the hard on, hoping that APP will do as they say it will? Looking for a cleaner powder than T7 that doesnt leave a crud ring?

Sounds like BH 209.

sabotloader 03-20-2011 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by MountainDevil54 (Post 3788764)
If T7 works so good for you guys, whats with the hard on, hoping that APP will do as they say it will? Looking for a cleaner powder than T7 that doesnt leave a crud ring?

Get your mouth out of the gutter and think about it.....

The 'crud ring' is not a part of the equation on my part. It is more about the possible velocity increase, using less powder and way less expensive than either alternative...

MountainDevil54 03-20-2011 08:40 AM

and limit yourself to a 250gr projectile. That leaves you out of elk huntin cuz you know a 250 just isnt big nuff for elk.

Expensive lawn fertilizer!

Muley Hunter 03-20-2011 08:41 AM


Originally Posted by sabotloader (Post 3788771)
Get your mouth out of the gutter and think about it.....

The 'crud ring' is not a part of the equation on my part. It is more about the possible velocity increase, using less powder and way less expensive than either alternative...

Why? Are you the only one shooting T7 that doesn't get a crud ring?

Gm54-120 03-20-2011 09:08 AM


Why? Are you the only one shooting T7 that doesn't get a crud ring?
I haven't tried it in any over my current MLs but one i sold has no problem with shooting at least 5 shots of T7 without swabbing. My old WinAPex though was horrible with T7 no matter what i tried.

Most of us that are trying it are doing it out of curiosity of "what if" its better than the older powder. They probably don't recommend hotter charges due to some imports with a history of mediocre barrel quality. Many of those older extruded barrel guns are still in circulation. Some of them don't recommend over 100gr charges (loose powder) anyway or a max 100gr charge with a 300gr bullet. My old WinApex made be BPI even mentioned this in the manual. They suggested reducing charges by 10% with 300gr bullets.

Since we have no reviews, at this point this is all speculation as to how good or bad the new powder will be and why they impose such restrictions.

builder459 03-20-2011 09:19 AM


Originally Posted by Gm54-120 (Post 3788784)
I haven't tried it in any over my current MLs but one i sold has no problem with shooting at least 5 shots of T7 without swabbing. My old WinAPex though was horrible with T7 no matter what i tried.

Most of us that are trying it are doing it out of curiosity of "what if" its better than the older powder. They probably don't recommend hotter charges due to some imports with a history of mediocre barrel quality. Many of those older extruded barrel guns are still in circulation. Some of them don't recommend over 100gr charges (loose powder) anyway or a max 100gr charge with a 300gr bullet. My old WinApex made be BPI even mentioned this in the manual. They suggested reducing charges by 10% with 300gr bullets.

Since we have no reviews, at this point this is all speculation as to how good or bad the new powder will be and why they impose such restrictions.

To be honest CVA has restriction they post on there site and in the manuals concerning bullet weights and powder charges. now would i fire a 460 conical from say a CVA Wolf or optima, of course i would, even though the manual states nothing over 400 gr. i feel this is covering there backsides. what i wouldn't do is fire that 460 gr bullet with a max load lol. Ray

MountainDevil54 03-20-2011 09:22 AM

Even the CEO shoots loads that arent recommended in the manual LOL. Its just old print in the manual that they havent fixed yet. Even on the blog they state that they limit to 100gr Loose as most anything over that, just blows out the end of the barrel, unburnt.

Muley Hunter 03-20-2011 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by MountainDevil54 (Post 3788789)
Even the CEO shoots loads that arent recommended in the manual LOL. Its just old print in the manual that they havent fixed yet. Even on the blog they state that they limit to 100gr Loose as most anything over that, just blows out the end of the barrel, unburnt.

Probably only true with real BP, but I know you know that.

builder459 03-20-2011 09:38 AM


Originally Posted by MountainDevil54 (Post 3788764)
If T7 works so good for you guys, whats with the hard on, hoping that APP will do as they say it will? Looking for a cleaner powder than T7 that doesnt leave a crud ring?

MD, let's not start getting nasty here please. in all fairness to SABOTLOADER, he has tried every powder ever made including BH209.he still prefers 777,which is a great powder with the exception of the crud ring.you for one should understand why he wants to try the new super powder, since you experiment with about every product made for muzzle loaders, not just limited to powders.i am interested in the super powder myself as it may be a alternative to dirty pyrodex in my wolverine.like GM mentioned the .250 gr weight limit, probably is a liability issue, which i totally agree with.i personally value SABOTLOADERS tests and input, even though i don't always agree with everything he says. he's been extremely helpful and kind to me and many other members on this site.i look forward to his review on the new super powder.. let's play nice.. Ray

sabotloader 03-20-2011 09:42 AM


Originally Posted by Muley Hunter (Post 3788774)
Why? Are you the only one shooting T7 that doesn't get a crud ring?

Believe me, i am not the only person shooting T7 with very litte effect of the crud ring. It is IMO all in how you treat the bore and I am not sure I have any magic formula(s) it just works. Bore Coat say they have the the fix for it.

But in all honesty - i know a lot of folks battle the crud ring and I know I am fortunate and I am thankful for that.

I really believe it to be a chemical reaction of materials in the powder and in the bore. I even hate to say this on the open forum, but i first lost the crud ring when i settled on using BB in a hot bore many years ago that really reduced the harness of the ring. Then moving to synthetic oils further reduced it, such as Montana X-Tream BC, Slip 2000 or Eazox. The other thing that I think might help is the use of regular Windex with ammonia as a cleaner and patch swab at the range.

Also I wonder if elevation and humidity do not have something to do with it. But then I have been told about a group of guys in Pennsyvania that show no effects of the crud ring either so that blows my elevation theory....

I just do not know but again I am not the only one that is pretty much 'crud ring' free.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:29 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.