Muzzleloader hunting
02-23-2011, 03:42 PM
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Iowa
Posts: 3
Muzzleloader hunting
What are some of the pros and cons of muzzleloader hunting? I have never owned or shot a muzzleloader but I am very interested in getting started, so I am trying to weigh the pros and cons of it muzzleloader hunting here in Iowa.
Thanks.
Thanks.
02-23-2011, 04:00 PM
#3
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: River Ridge, LA (Suburb of New Orleans)
Posts: 10,917
I'm not sure a pro/con list is of any real value. From a pure effectiveness standpoint the cons outweigh the pros by a fairly wide margin because muzzle loaders can't match a 30-06 in energy, trajectory, range, or speed of a follow up shot. ML hunting either tickles your fancy or does not. It tickles mine bunches.
Last edited by Semisane; 02-23-2011 at 06:27 PM.
02-23-2011, 05:34 PM
#4
Typical Buck
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Lake Saint Louis MO
Posts: 723
First off welcome. Here are a few of mine.
Pros: Extends hunting season
Provides hours of testing bullets, loads, etc (fun times)
Fair game, you shoot and miss oh well that buck goes on
Smoke and fire
Forces you to respect the game and your gun knowing that a muzzy cannot outshoot a centerfire
Cons: Extends hunting season (usually so dang gum tired the end of the year)
Provides hours of testing bullets, loads, etc (fun times)
(expensive if you like to shoot a lot and just need that better bullet)
Fair game, you shoot and miss oh well that buck goes on
(usually that buck of a lifetime, I missed a 16 pointer one year as I had the shakes so bad and shot and missed, he went off for another day)
Smoke and fire (rotten egg smell of real blackpowder and Pyrodex)
Forces you to respect the game and your gun knowing that a muzzy cannot outshoot a centerfire (knowing that the trophy buck is out at the 250 yard mark and you cannot do anything about it)
If you are in doubt try it. I did and had no help until I found this site a while back. Buy an entry type gun and get some supplies and shoot it. If you cannot do that find a buddy who shoots a muzzy and have him take you shooting. I have been shooting and do not own any more centerfires. It is very addictive and a lot more fun for sure especially when you connect with that first deer.
Pros: Extends hunting season
Provides hours of testing bullets, loads, etc (fun times)
Fair game, you shoot and miss oh well that buck goes on
Smoke and fire
Forces you to respect the game and your gun knowing that a muzzy cannot outshoot a centerfire
Cons: Extends hunting season (usually so dang gum tired the end of the year)
Provides hours of testing bullets, loads, etc (fun times)
(expensive if you like to shoot a lot and just need that better bullet)
Fair game, you shoot and miss oh well that buck goes on
(usually that buck of a lifetime, I missed a 16 pointer one year as I had the shakes so bad and shot and missed, he went off for another day)
Smoke and fire (rotten egg smell of real blackpowder and Pyrodex)
Forces you to respect the game and your gun knowing that a muzzy cannot outshoot a centerfire (knowing that the trophy buck is out at the 250 yard mark and you cannot do anything about it)
If you are in doubt try it. I did and had no help until I found this site a while back. Buy an entry type gun and get some supplies and shoot it. If you cannot do that find a buddy who shoots a muzzy and have him take you shooting. I have been shooting and do not own any more centerfires. It is very addictive and a lot more fun for sure especially when you connect with that first deer.
02-23-2011, 06:03 PM
#5
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Northern Chautauqua Co. N.Y.
Posts: 2,976
MLer Hunting teaches you to take your Best Shot as you only have one. It teaches you disciplin and makes you a better Hunter.
You must know your MLer inside and out and what it likes to shoot, how to Clean it and maintain it. When you know this stuff you'll be on your way to a Great Sport. The Pros are everything is good and fun about it and it extends your Hunting Season. the Cons are you only have one shot and you have to keep it Clean, simple as that.
(BP)
You must know your MLer inside and out and what it likes to shoot, how to Clean it and maintain it. When you know this stuff you'll be on your way to a Great Sport. The Pros are everything is good and fun about it and it extends your Hunting Season. the Cons are you only have one shot and you have to keep it Clean, simple as that.
(BP)
02-24-2011, 12:22 AM
#8
Fork Horn
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Indiana
Posts: 366
Pros: Extends hunting season
Provides hours of testing bullets, loads, etc (fun times)
Fair game, you shoot and miss oh well that buck goes on
Smoke and fire
Forces you to respect the game and your gun knowing that a muzzy cannot outshoot a centerfire
If you are in doubt try it. I did and had no help until I found this site a while back. Buy an entry type gun and get some supplies and shoot it. If you cannot do that find a buddy who shoots a muzzy and have him take you shooting. I have been shooting and do not own any more centerfires. It is very addictive and a lot more fun for sure especially when you connect with that first deer.
MLer Hunting teaches you to take your Best Shot as you only have one. It teaches you disciplin and makes you a better Hunter.
You must know your MLer inside and out and what it likes to shoot, how to Clean it and maintain it. When you know this stuff you'll be on your way to a Great Sport. The Pros are everything is good and fun about it and it extends your Hunting Season. the Cons are you only have one shot and you have to keep it Clean, simple as that.
(BP)
You must know your MLer inside and out and what it likes to shoot, how to Clean it and maintain it. When you know this stuff you'll be on your way to a Great Sport. The Pros are everything is good and fun about it and it extends your Hunting Season. the Cons are you only have one shot and you have to keep it Clean, simple as that.
(BP)
If you don't know anybody that shoots muzzleloaders, I would dive in head first! Your never going to know for sure if you like it unless you get some hands-on experience with this type of shooting.
There are some really great deals on new muzzleloaders right now for around $200-$250(if you decide to buy just ask some of the forum members for examples)
There is a TON of great info in the archives. Just about any question can be answered by using the "search function" to research the archives.
GOOD LUCK AND WELCOME
02-24-2011, 06:50 AM
#10
Typical Buck
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: southwestern va
Posts: 753
like anything, you can choose to get into someting really heavily or just enough to be effective. I like ml because it extends my season, and it also puts me in the woods during the peak of the rut here when gun season still hasnt started. i guess i was lucky but i found a bullet/powder combo that worked really well quickly, and other than buying some different cleaning products and equipment, it really hasnt cost me much time or money other than buying the rifle itsself. From my perspective the pro is more hunting time, and no cons